"Knowledge like timber shouldn't be mush use till they are seasoned"
About this Quote
Holmes turns a homely carpentry truth into a rebuke of intellectual impatience. Timber, if used green, warps, cracks, and ruins whatever you tried to build; knowledge, if put to work too early, does the same to judgment. The line isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-hasty: it’s aimed at the student who memorizes, the reformer who lectures, the pundit who “knows” before they’ve tested a thought against reality.
The phrasing matters. “Knowledge like timber” drags lofty learning down into the workshop, where utility is the point and materials have limits. That demotes the romantic fantasy of instant genius and replaces it with craft: time, pressure, and exposure are part of making something reliable. “Seasoned” does double duty. It’s the literal process of drying wood, and it’s the moral-social process of being seasoned by experience. Holmes is implying that raw information isn’t yet knowledge in the full sense; it needs metabolizing.
The subtext is a gentle elitism typical of a 19th-century physician-poet who lived around Harvard and the Brahmin class: there’s a proper tempo to becoming authoritative, and it’s slower than ambition would like. In a culture vibrating with progress, inventions, and political certainty, Holmes offers a caution that feels surprisingly modern: speed produces content, not wisdom. The sentence itself is a kind of seasoning - plain, compressed, built to last. (The quirky “mush use” likely reflects a transcription error for “much used,” but the point survives the splinters.)
The phrasing matters. “Knowledge like timber” drags lofty learning down into the workshop, where utility is the point and materials have limits. That demotes the romantic fantasy of instant genius and replaces it with craft: time, pressure, and exposure are part of making something reliable. “Seasoned” does double duty. It’s the literal process of drying wood, and it’s the moral-social process of being seasoned by experience. Holmes is implying that raw information isn’t yet knowledge in the full sense; it needs metabolizing.
The subtext is a gentle elitism typical of a 19th-century physician-poet who lived around Harvard and the Brahmin class: there’s a proper tempo to becoming authoritative, and it’s slower than ambition would like. In a culture vibrating with progress, inventions, and political certainty, Holmes offers a caution that feels surprisingly modern: speed produces content, not wisdom. The sentence itself is a kind of seasoning - plain, compressed, built to last. (The quirky “mush use” likely reflects a transcription error for “much used,” but the point survives the splinters.)
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: Complete Project Gutenberg Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr. Works (Holmes, Oliver Wendell, 1894)EBook #3252
Evidence: but recently knowledge and timber shouldnt be much used till they are seasoned ph Other candidates (1) Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr. (Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr.) compilation73.8% 6 knowledge and timber shouldnt be much used till they are seasoned ch 6 the men |
More Quotes by Oliver
Add to List




