"Labor is work that leaves no trace behind it when it is finished, or if it does, as in the case of the tilled field, this product of human activity requires still more labor, incessant, tireless labor, to maintain its identity as a "work" of man"
About this Quote
McCarthy draws a ruthless line between what we like to romanticize as “honest work” and what she wants us to see as labor: activity that vanishes the moment you stop doing it. The sentence is engineered to feel exhausting. Clause stacks on clause, and the phrase “incessant, tireless labor” lands like a verdict, not a description. You can almost hear the breathlessness of keeping a household running, a body fed, a field productive, a life maintained. The point isn’t that labor is ignoble; it’s that it’s structurally unable to secure recognition on its own terms because it produces no stable artifact to point to.
Her telling example, the tilled field, is a quiet dismantling of pastoral fantasy. Even when labor appears to leave a visible “product,” nature and time immediately begin erasing it. The field only stays a human achievement through constant repetition. McCarthy’s subtext is political and cultural: modern societies disproportionately reward “works” that can be owned, displayed, archived, monetized, or credited to a singular author, while the maintenance that makes those works (and the people who make them) possible is treated as background noise.
Context matters: mid-century American life was saturated with talk of progress, productivity, and the dignity of work, even as domestic and service labor - often done by women and the poor - remained socially minimized and economically underpaid. McCarthy’s intent is to puncture that moral glow. She’s insisting we confront a bleak arithmetic: if the labor that sustains everything is designed to disappear, the people doing it will be trained to disappear with it.
Her telling example, the tilled field, is a quiet dismantling of pastoral fantasy. Even when labor appears to leave a visible “product,” nature and time immediately begin erasing it. The field only stays a human achievement through constant repetition. McCarthy’s subtext is political and cultural: modern societies disproportionately reward “works” that can be owned, displayed, archived, monetized, or credited to a singular author, while the maintenance that makes those works (and the people who make them) possible is treated as background noise.
Context matters: mid-century American life was saturated with talk of progress, productivity, and the dignity of work, even as domestic and service labor - often done by women and the poor - remained socially minimized and economically underpaid. McCarthy’s intent is to puncture that moral glow. She’s insisting we confront a bleak arithmetic: if the labor that sustains everything is designed to disappear, the people doing it will be trained to disappear with it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work |
|---|---|
| Source | Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (1958), section on "Labor" — passage discusses labor as activity leaving no durable trace and requiring continual maintenance (commonly cited formulation in Arendt's work). |
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List








