"Language should find itself in the physical world, and not end up locked in an idea in somebody's head"
About this Quote
Smithson is warning against the museumification of language: the way words can become sealed off as private concepts, pristine and airless, instead of doing the dirtier work of touching matter. Coming from a key figure in Land Art, this isn’t a poetic preference so much as an aesthetic program. His most famous projects - Spiral Jetty, the non-sites, the essays that read like field reports - insist that meaning happens through placement, scale, weather, entropy. “Find itself” is doing a lot here: language isn’t a sovereign tool that captures reality; it’s something that has to be re-situated, even humbled, by the physical world.
The subtext pushes back on a mid-century drift toward pure theory, studio-bound formalism, and the fantasy that art (or criticism) can be completed at the level of ideas. Smithson mistrusted that cleanliness. He wanted language to behave like his materials: to erode, to scatter, to pick up grit. Locked in someone’s head, language becomes property, a closed system; out in the world, it becomes public, contingent, and accountable to consequence. That’s also a quiet critique of authority: the “somebody” could be the critic, the curator, the academic, the artist - anyone who treats interpretation as ownership.
Context matters: late-60s/early-70s America, when artists were leaving the gallery to work with quarries, salt lakes, highways, industrial ruins. Smithson’s line reads like a manifesto for thinking as a form of site-specific labor: words that have to withstand wind, distance, and time, not just agreement.
The subtext pushes back on a mid-century drift toward pure theory, studio-bound formalism, and the fantasy that art (or criticism) can be completed at the level of ideas. Smithson mistrusted that cleanliness. He wanted language to behave like his materials: to erode, to scatter, to pick up grit. Locked in someone’s head, language becomes property, a closed system; out in the world, it becomes public, contingent, and accountable to consequence. That’s also a quiet critique of authority: the “somebody” could be the critic, the curator, the academic, the artist - anyone who treats interpretation as ownership.
Context matters: late-60s/early-70s America, when artists were leaving the gallery to work with quarries, salt lakes, highways, industrial ruins. Smithson’s line reads like a manifesto for thinking as a form of site-specific labor: words that have to withstand wind, distance, and time, not just agreement.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
