"Lapped in poetry, wrapped in the picturesque, armed with logical sentences and inalienable words"
About this Quote
Broyard’s line dresses criticism the way he thought it ought to dress itself: not in lab coat neutrality, but in tailored language that can pass in public and still carry a blade. “Lapped in poetry, wrapped in the picturesque” turns prose into fabric, something felt against the skin. He’s arguing, implicitly, that ideas don’t enter us as raw data; they enter as texture, image, rhythm. The critic’s first obligation isn’t to be correct in a courtroom sense, but to make thought sensuous enough to be lived with.
Then he pivots from softness to force: “armed with logical sentences and inalienable words.” The charm isn’t an escape from rigor; it’s camouflage for it. Logic becomes a weapon, but a civilized one: sentences that can take apart sloppy thinking without sounding like a scold. “Inalienable words” is the slyest phrase here, borrowing the language of political rights to claim a kind of moral property in language itself. Some words, some naming, shouldn’t be bargained away to fashion, euphemism, or propaganda.
Context matters: Broyard came up in mid-century American letters, when criticism often split between academic specialization and journalistic breeziness. His persona insisted on a third way: high style with street-level readability, the cultivated voice as a form of democratic access. The subtext is almost polemical: if you can’t make your intelligence beautiful, you’re not done thinking yet. And if you can’t make it logical, your beauty is just decor.
Then he pivots from softness to force: “armed with logical sentences and inalienable words.” The charm isn’t an escape from rigor; it’s camouflage for it. Logic becomes a weapon, but a civilized one: sentences that can take apart sloppy thinking without sounding like a scold. “Inalienable words” is the slyest phrase here, borrowing the language of political rights to claim a kind of moral property in language itself. Some words, some naming, shouldn’t be bargained away to fashion, euphemism, or propaganda.
Context matters: Broyard came up in mid-century American letters, when criticism often split between academic specialization and journalistic breeziness. His persona insisted on a third way: high style with street-level readability, the cultivated voice as a form of democratic access. The subtext is almost polemical: if you can’t make your intelligence beautiful, you’re not done thinking yet. And if you can’t make it logical, your beauty is just decor.
Quote Details
| Topic | Poetry |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Anatole
Add to List






