"Larger deficits are necessary and proper means to mitigate unemployment as the far greater evil in terms of human welfare"
About this Quote
“Necessary and proper” is lawyerly language smuggled into economics, and that’s the point. Vickrey isn’t merely arguing that deficits can be useful; he’s asserting legitimacy. In the late-20th-century climate of deficit panic and moralizing about balanced budgets, he reframes fiscal red ink as a tool of constitutional seriousness rather than political indulgence. The phrasing quietly flips the burden of proof: the scandal isn’t borrowing, it’s tolerating joblessness.
The subtext is a values fight disguised as technocracy. Unemployment is labeled “the far greater evil,” a moral ranking that punctures the common habit of treating deficits as the obvious adult concern. Vickrey is making a welfare calculus: idle people mean wasted skills, frayed communities, deferred family formation, poorer health, and the corrosive humiliation of being “unneeded.” A deficit, by contrast, is an accounting artifact that can be managed, rolled over, or inflated away; unemployment is lived experience that compounds.
Context matters. Vickrey, a Nobel-winning economist associated with public finance and pragmatic policy, writes in the shadow of post-1970s stagflation and the rise of anti-Keynesian politics, when “government spending” became a cultural villain. His intent is to rehabilitate countercyclical fiscal policy not as a partisan preference but as a humane obligation. The line also anticipates modern debates about austerity: he’s warning that treating deficits as the supreme evil invites governments to choose the optics of prudence over the substance of welfare.
The subtext is a values fight disguised as technocracy. Unemployment is labeled “the far greater evil,” a moral ranking that punctures the common habit of treating deficits as the obvious adult concern. Vickrey is making a welfare calculus: idle people mean wasted skills, frayed communities, deferred family formation, poorer health, and the corrosive humiliation of being “unneeded.” A deficit, by contrast, is an accounting artifact that can be managed, rolled over, or inflated away; unemployment is lived experience that compounds.
Context matters. Vickrey, a Nobel-winning economist associated with public finance and pragmatic policy, writes in the shadow of post-1970s stagflation and the rise of anti-Keynesian politics, when “government spending” became a cultural villain. His intent is to rehabilitate countercyclical fiscal policy not as a partisan preference but as a humane obligation. The line also anticipates modern debates about austerity: he’s warning that treating deficits as the supreme evil invites governments to choose the optics of prudence over the substance of welfare.
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List



