"Let one persuade many, and he becomes confirmed and convinced, and cares for no better evidence"
About this Quote
Mass persuasion doesn’t just move crowds; it hardens the persuader. Wright is sketching a psychological trap that feels almost tailor-made for modern media ecosystems: the moment your argument starts working socially, it starts feeling true internally, and the need for independent proof begins to look like pedantry. The line turns on a sly inversion of the usual story. We worry about gullible audiences. Wright worries about the evangelist.
The phrasing is clinical and quietly damning. “Confirmed and convinced” doubles the claim, as if belief isn’t a single click but a ratcheting mechanism: repetition, applause, and public commitment tighten the screws. “Cares for no better evidence” is the knife twist. Better evidence exists; he just stops wanting it. The subtext is that conviction is not merely an epistemic state but a social reward system. Once your identity, status, or livelihood is tied to being right, evidence becomes negotiable and doubt becomes betrayal.
Context matters: Wright sits in the 19th-century current of American pragmatism and early scientific naturalism, wary of metaphysics and grand systems built from charisma rather than testable grounds. He’s also writing in a culture thick with revivals, reform movements, and confident public moralizing. His target isn’t faith per se; it’s the self-sealing feedback loop where persuasion becomes its own “proof.”
What makes the sentence work is its compressed realism: it anticipates how public performance reshapes private belief. The persuader becomes the first captive of his own rhetoric.
The phrasing is clinical and quietly damning. “Confirmed and convinced” doubles the claim, as if belief isn’t a single click but a ratcheting mechanism: repetition, applause, and public commitment tighten the screws. “Cares for no better evidence” is the knife twist. Better evidence exists; he just stops wanting it. The subtext is that conviction is not merely an epistemic state but a social reward system. Once your identity, status, or livelihood is tied to being right, evidence becomes negotiable and doubt becomes betrayal.
Context matters: Wright sits in the 19th-century current of American pragmatism and early scientific naturalism, wary of metaphysics and grand systems built from charisma rather than testable grounds. He’s also writing in a culture thick with revivals, reform movements, and confident public moralizing. His target isn’t faith per se; it’s the self-sealing feedback loop where persuasion becomes its own “proof.”
What makes the sentence work is its compressed realism: it anticipates how public performance reshapes private belief. The persuader becomes the first captive of his own rhetoric.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Chauncey
Add to List
