"Let's put it this way: if you are a novelist, I think you start out with a 20 word idea, and you work at it and you wind up with a 200,000 word novel. We, picture-book people, or at least I, start out with 200,000 words and I reduce it to 20"
About this Quote
Carle flips the prestige hierarchy with a single, sly reversal: the novelist expands; the picture-book maker distills. It lands because it punctures the grown-up assumption that “short” means “simple,” and because it frames children’s literature as an act of ruthless craft rather than cute inspiration. The numbers are obviously exaggerated, but that’s the point. Hyperbole becomes a measuring stick for effort: compression is labor.
The specific intent is partly defensive, partly evangelical. Carle is explaining to adults - publishers, critics, parents - that writing for very young readers isn’t a lesser form; it’s a high-wire one. When he says he “starts out with 200,000 words,” he’s really talking about the messy surplus behind a clean page: the drafts that got cut, the tonal calibrations, the cognitive empathy required to see the world at a child’s height without talking down to them. A picture book has to do what a novel can do with chapters: establish a voice, build tension, and deliver emotional payoff, but with almost no room for throat-clearing.
The subtext is a philosophy of restraint. Carle’s best books feel inevitable, almost effortless, which is exactly what he’s revealing as illusion. Context matters, too: his era helped cement the picture book as a serious art object, where design, pacing, and image-text interplay carry narrative weight. The “20 words” aren’t just the text; they’re the tip of a storytelling iceberg.
The specific intent is partly defensive, partly evangelical. Carle is explaining to adults - publishers, critics, parents - that writing for very young readers isn’t a lesser form; it’s a high-wire one. When he says he “starts out with 200,000 words,” he’s really talking about the messy surplus behind a clean page: the drafts that got cut, the tonal calibrations, the cognitive empathy required to see the world at a child’s height without talking down to them. A picture book has to do what a novel can do with chapters: establish a voice, build tension, and deliver emotional payoff, but with almost no room for throat-clearing.
The subtext is a philosophy of restraint. Carle’s best books feel inevitable, almost effortless, which is exactly what he’s revealing as illusion. Context matters, too: his era helped cement the picture book as a serious art object, where design, pacing, and image-text interplay carry narrative weight. The “20 words” aren’t just the text; they’re the tip of a storytelling iceberg.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Eric
Add to List
