"Like a plant that starts up in showers and sunshine and does not know which has best helped it to grow, it is difficult to say whether the hard things or the pleasant things did me the most good"
About this Quote
The subtext is quietly radical for a 19th-century poet whose life intersected with early industrial labor (Larcom worked in Lowell’s mills before becoming an educator and writer). In that world, “hard things” could mean grinding necessity, not character-building spice. The line’s restraint reads like a refusal to romanticize suffering while still acknowledging its formative force. “Pleasant things” aren’t dismissed as frivolous; they are presented as equally structural. That balance pushes against a culture - then and now - that treats deprivation as authenticity and comfort as moral weakness.
The sentence also works rhetorically because it collapses the binary it sets up. “Showers and sunshine” aren’t opposites so much as partners in the same ecosystem. Larcom’s intent feels less like advice than calibration: a reminder that becoming oneself is often an untrackable mix of bruises and blessings, and that the ledger we keep in hindsight is usually fiction.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: A New England Girlhood (Lucy Larcom, 1889)
Evidence: Like a plant that starts up in showers and sunshine and does not know which has best helped it to grow, it is difficult to say whether the hard things or the pleasant things did me most good. (Chapter VII, "Beginning to Work"; exact page not verified from the scanned first edition text consulted). This quote appears in Lucy Larcom's own autobiographical book A New England Girlhood, outlined from memory, first published in Boston and New York by Houghton, Mifflin and Company in 1889. The Library of Congress catalog confirms the 1889 publication and the chapter list, including Chapter VII, "Beginning to Work." The wording commonly circulated online usually adds "did me the most good," but the primary-source text reads "did me most good" without "the." Based on the primary-source evidence located, this is the earliest verified publication found. Other candidates (1) A New England Girlhood, Outlined from Memory (Lucy Larcom, 2025) compilation96.5% ... Like a plant that starts up in showers and sunshine and does not know which has best helped it to grow , it is di... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Larcom, Lucy. (2026, March 10). Like a plant that starts up in showers and sunshine and does not know which has best helped it to grow, it is difficult to say whether the hard things or the pleasant things did me the most good. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/like-a-plant-that-starts-up-in-showers-and-146815/
Chicago Style
Larcom, Lucy. "Like a plant that starts up in showers and sunshine and does not know which has best helped it to grow, it is difficult to say whether the hard things or the pleasant things did me the most good." FixQuotes. March 10, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/like-a-plant-that-starts-up-in-showers-and-146815/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Like a plant that starts up in showers and sunshine and does not know which has best helped it to grow, it is difficult to say whether the hard things or the pleasant things did me the most good." FixQuotes, 10 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/like-a-plant-that-starts-up-in-showers-and-146815/. Accessed 11 Mar. 2026.






