"Like pictures, men should be judged by their merits and not by their defects"
About this Quote
A good picture isn’t admired because it’s flawless; it’s admired because something in it holds. Bainbridge Colby’s line borrows that aesthetic logic and tries to smuggle it into public judgment, where the eye is always looking for stains. The phrasing is doing careful work: “Like pictures” invites you to think as a viewer before you think as a juror. It shifts evaluation from moral accounting to composition - what the whole adds up to, not the scratches you can circle with a finger.
Colby was a public servant in an era when reputations were currency and scandal was becoming mass entertainment. Read against the early 20th-century backdrop - muckraking journalism, wartime loyalty tests, the emerging machinery of national politics - the quote plays as a defense of civic fairness under conditions designed to produce suspicion. “Defects” here isn’t just personal vice; it’s also the convenient label opponents slap on complexity: an awkward vote, an unpopular client, the wrong accent, the wrong friend.
The intent is not naive optimism about human goodness. It’s a bureaucrat’s plea for proportionality: judge the output, the service, the measurable contribution - “merits” - rather than reduce a person to their most photogenic failure. The subtext, though, cuts both ways. Asking to be judged “by merits” is also how institutions launder their own blind spots: elevating achievements while treating harms as minor blemishes. Like a portrait retouched for display, the frame can flatter as much as it clarifies.
Colby was a public servant in an era when reputations were currency and scandal was becoming mass entertainment. Read against the early 20th-century backdrop - muckraking journalism, wartime loyalty tests, the emerging machinery of national politics - the quote plays as a defense of civic fairness under conditions designed to produce suspicion. “Defects” here isn’t just personal vice; it’s also the convenient label opponents slap on complexity: an awkward vote, an unpopular client, the wrong accent, the wrong friend.
The intent is not naive optimism about human goodness. It’s a bureaucrat’s plea for proportionality: judge the output, the service, the measurable contribution - “merits” - rather than reduce a person to their most photogenic failure. The subtext, though, cuts both ways. Asking to be judged “by merits” is also how institutions launder their own blind spots: elevating achievements while treating harms as minor blemishes. Like a portrait retouched for display, the frame can flatter as much as it clarifies.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Bainbridge
Add to List






