"Like the winds that we come we know not whence and blow whither soever they list, the forces of society are derived from an obscure and distant origin. They arise before the date of philosophy, from the instincts, not the speculations of men"
About this Quote
Ferguson is smuggling a warning into a bit of elegant weather-talk: society is not a machine you can disassemble on a workbench, and it certainly isn’t a neat diagram produced by philosophers after the fact. The wind metaphor matters because it flatters human ambition (we name the winds, predict them, occasionally harness them) while reminding us we don’t author them. Social order, for Ferguson, has the same unnerving autonomy: it moves through us more than we move it.
The subtext is a direct shot at Enlightenment hubris, especially the rationalist fantasy that institutions can be designed from first principles. By insisting these forces “arise before the date of philosophy,” he positions thought as a late-arriving narrator, not the prime mover. Philosophy doesn’t create society; it offers postmortems and just-so stories. What actually builds the world is “instincts” - habit, imitation, rivalry, fear, status-seeking, cooperation under pressure. That’s a proto-social-science move: he’s describing emergent order before the vocabulary existed.
Context sharpens the edge. Writing in a Britain remade by commerce, empire, and early industrialization, Ferguson watched older bonds dissolve and new systems harden without anyone voting on them. His point isn’t anti-intellectual; it’s anti-overconfident. Treating society as a product of “speculations” invites the reformer’s classic mistake: mistaking the map for the terrain, then bulldozing the terrain to match the map. The rhetorical trick is that he makes humility feel like realism, not resignation.
The subtext is a direct shot at Enlightenment hubris, especially the rationalist fantasy that institutions can be designed from first principles. By insisting these forces “arise before the date of philosophy,” he positions thought as a late-arriving narrator, not the prime mover. Philosophy doesn’t create society; it offers postmortems and just-so stories. What actually builds the world is “instincts” - habit, imitation, rivalry, fear, status-seeking, cooperation under pressure. That’s a proto-social-science move: he’s describing emergent order before the vocabulary existed.
Context sharpens the edge. Writing in a Britain remade by commerce, empire, and early industrialization, Ferguson watched older bonds dissolve and new systems harden without anyone voting on them. His point isn’t anti-intellectual; it’s anti-overconfident. Treating society as a product of “speculations” invites the reformer’s classic mistake: mistaking the map for the terrain, then bulldozing the terrain to match the map. The rhetorical trick is that he makes humility feel like realism, not resignation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Adam
Add to List
