"Like their predecessors, the Presidents of today just throw up their hands"
About this Quote
Ambrose’s line lands like a historian’s weary eye-roll: the modern presidency isn’t uniquely besieged, just newly addicted to the performance of helplessness. “Like their predecessors” is the dagger. It punctures the convenient myth that today’s crises are unprecedented and that current leaders are victims of some novel era of complexity. Ambrose is reminding readers that the job has always come with constraint, conflict, and failure; what changes is the script presidents use to narrate those limits.
“Throw up their hands” is doing double duty. On its face, it’s exasperation - the gesture of a person overwhelmed by forces beyond control. Subtextually, it’s a tactic: the public display of frustration becomes a kind of alibi. If the president is seen as stymied by Congress, the courts, bureaucracy, geopolitics, or “the system,” responsibility diffuses. The gesture asks for sympathy while lowering expectations, a subtle form of political risk management. It also flatters voters by implying the real culprit is an unruly world, not a leader’s choices.
As a historian, Ambrose is allergic to present-tense self-pity. His work often emphasized contingency and agency: decisions made by imperfect people inside imperfect institutions. This sentence pushes back against the modern media environment that rewards melodrama and “impossible job” narratives. Ambrose isn’t denying complexity; he’s interrogating the comfort of resignation. The jab is that presidents don’t only inherit constraints - they also inherit excuses.
“Throw up their hands” is doing double duty. On its face, it’s exasperation - the gesture of a person overwhelmed by forces beyond control. Subtextually, it’s a tactic: the public display of frustration becomes a kind of alibi. If the president is seen as stymied by Congress, the courts, bureaucracy, geopolitics, or “the system,” responsibility diffuses. The gesture asks for sympathy while lowering expectations, a subtle form of political risk management. It also flatters voters by implying the real culprit is an unruly world, not a leader’s choices.
As a historian, Ambrose is allergic to present-tense self-pity. His work often emphasized contingency and agency: decisions made by imperfect people inside imperfect institutions. This sentence pushes back against the modern media environment that rewards melodrama and “impossible job” narratives. Ambrose isn’t denying complexity; he’s interrogating the comfort of resignation. The jab is that presidents don’t only inherit constraints - they also inherit excuses.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List








