"Like Venice, Italy, New Orleans is a cultural treasure. And everyone who lived in the city should be allowed to come back. But that doesn't mean that they all should live in exactly the same spot that they lived before"
About this Quote
The pivot word is "But". He offers an ethical baseline - people should be allowed to come back - then immediately narrows it into a logistical argument about geography. On paper, it sounds practical: floods don’t respect nostalgia. In context, it echoes a post-Katrina debate where "public safety" and "smart rebuilding" often doubled as a polite vocabulary for reshaping the city’s demographics, housing stock, and political power. "Allowed" suggests gatekeeping; the right to return is framed not as a given, but as something dispensed by institutions with maps and budgets.
McMahon, a mainstream entertainer with a genial national persona, delivers this as common sense, which is precisely why it lands. The soft tone smuggles in a harder proposition: cultural preservation can coexist with displacement, as long as the displacement is described as relocation rather than removal. The line reassures America that it can mourn New Orleans, celebrate its mystique, and still endorse a rebuild that doesn’t restore the old social contract.
Quote Details
| Topic | Embrace Change |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
McMahon, Ed. (2026, January 17). Like Venice, Italy, New Orleans is a cultural treasure. And everyone who lived in the city should be allowed to come back. But that doesn't mean that they all should live in exactly the same spot that they lived before. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/like-venice-italy-new-orleans-is-a-cultural-74314/
Chicago Style
McMahon, Ed. "Like Venice, Italy, New Orleans is a cultural treasure. And everyone who lived in the city should be allowed to come back. But that doesn't mean that they all should live in exactly the same spot that they lived before." FixQuotes. January 17, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/like-venice-italy-new-orleans-is-a-cultural-74314/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Like Venice, Italy, New Orleans is a cultural treasure. And everyone who lived in the city should be allowed to come back. But that doesn't mean that they all should live in exactly the same spot that they lived before." FixQuotes, 17 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/like-venice-italy-new-orleans-is-a-cultural-74314/. Accessed 11 Feb. 2026.



