"Listening is a magnetic and strange thing, a creative force. The friends who listen to us are the ones we move toward. When we are listened to, it creates us, makes us unfold and expand"
About this Quote
Menninger frames listening not as a polite social skill but as a kind of psychic gravity: “magnetic and strange,” an invisible force that rearranges where we stand and who we become. It’s a quietly audacious claim for a psychiatrist in the 20th century, when the culture was busy sanctifying talk - confession, catharsis, the heroic monologue of the self. Menninger flips the spotlight. The real power, he suggests, belongs to the person who can hold another human’s inner weather without trying to fix it, redirect it, or steal the scene.
The line “creative force” is doing double duty. Listening is creative because it produces something new - not advice, but a fuller version of the speaker. Menninger’s subtext is relational: identity isn’t minted in isolation; it’s co-authored. “When we are listened to, it creates us” carries a clinical echo of the therapy room, where the patient’s story often arrives fragmented, ashamed, or rehearsed for dismissal. Attentive listening becomes an antidote to that dismissal, giving the speaker permission to risk complexity. They “unfold,” a verb that implies patience and time, not interrogation.
There’s also a mild indictment here: we “move toward” the friends who listen because most people don’t. In a society that rewards quick takes and competitive conversation, Menninger’s idea remains unsettlingly contemporary. He’s arguing that attention isn’t just kindness; it’s infrastructure for personhood.
The line “creative force” is doing double duty. Listening is creative because it produces something new - not advice, but a fuller version of the speaker. Menninger’s subtext is relational: identity isn’t minted in isolation; it’s co-authored. “When we are listened to, it creates us” carries a clinical echo of the therapy room, where the patient’s story often arrives fragmented, ashamed, or rehearsed for dismissal. Attentive listening becomes an antidote to that dismissal, giving the speaker permission to risk complexity. They “unfold,” a verb that implies patience and time, not interrogation.
There’s also a mild indictment here: we “move toward” the friends who listen because most people don’t. In a society that rewards quick takes and competitive conversation, Menninger’s idea remains unsettlingly contemporary. He’s arguing that attention isn’t just kindness; it’s infrastructure for personhood.
Quote Details
| Topic | Friendship |
|---|
More Quotes by Karl
Add to List



