"Local color has a fatal tendency to remain local; but it is also true that the universal often borders on the void"
About this Quote
Allen is taking a sly swipe at two opposing literary vanities: the writer who believes a place name and a few dialect spellings automatically equal depth, and the writer who flees specificity in the hope of reaching “everyone,” only to end up with air. The line works because it refuses to flatter either camp. “Local color” is painted as seductive but “fatal” in a very practical way: it can trap a story inside its own postcard, legible only to those who already know the codes. What’s “local” risks becoming trivia, anthropology without urgency, atmosphere without stakes.
Then comes the pivot that sharpens the knife. The “universal” isn’t redeemed as the grown-up alternative; it “often borders on the void.” Allen’s subtext is that universality isn’t achieved by sanding down details, but by making the particular so charged it travels. Strip away time, place, idiom, and you don’t get timelessness-you get blankness, a theme so generalized it stops meaning anything at all. It’s an aesthetic warning disguised as a paradox.
Contextually, Allen writes in an era when American letters were wrestling with regionalism and nationalism: how to sound distinctively American without turning art into a souvenir shop, how to speak broadly without dissolving into moral platitudes. His sentence argues for the hard middle path: the work that starts in a real room, with real weather and real speech, but aims past the zip code toward pressure points that readers recognize in their own lives.
Then comes the pivot that sharpens the knife. The “universal” isn’t redeemed as the grown-up alternative; it “often borders on the void.” Allen’s subtext is that universality isn’t achieved by sanding down details, but by making the particular so charged it travels. Strip away time, place, idiom, and you don’t get timelessness-you get blankness, a theme so generalized it stops meaning anything at all. It’s an aesthetic warning disguised as a paradox.
Contextually, Allen writes in an era when American letters were wrestling with regionalism and nationalism: how to sound distinctively American without turning art into a souvenir shop, how to speak broadly without dissolving into moral platitudes. His sentence argues for the hard middle path: the work that starts in a real room, with real weather and real speech, but aims past the zip code toward pressure points that readers recognize in their own lives.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Hervey
Add to List
