"Looking back, I imagine I was always writing. Twaddle it was too. But better far write twaddle or anything, anything, than nothing at all"
About this Quote
Mansfield turns self-deprecation into a manifesto. “Twaddle” is a deliciously dismissive word: comic, a little cruel, and strategically chosen. It shrinks the young writer’s work down to nonsense so she can talk about it without sentimentality. But the punchline lands in the second sentence, when she repeats “anything, anything” like an incantation. The rhythm is nervous and insistent, as if she’s arguing with an internal censor that keeps asking, Is this good enough? Her answer: keep producing. Quantity isn’t the enemy of quality; silence is.
The subtext is partly about class and permission. Mansfield, a colonial New Zealander who fought her way into the literary world of London modernism, knew how fragile creative legitimacy could feel, especially for a woman expected to be charming rather than ambitious. Calling her early work “twaddle” pre-empts the critics: she will shame herself first, then keep writing anyway. It’s defiance dressed as modesty.
Context matters, too: modernism prized the polished fragment, the perfected short story, the sentence that looks effortless. Mansfield reveals the grubby backstage labor behind that elegance. She doesn’t romanticize the muse; she champions practice, even embarrassing practice. The line quietly rewrites the origin story of talent: not lightning, but accumulation. If you want the Mansfield who can make a room vibrate with a single detail, you have to tolerate the Mansfield who once wrote nonsense - and, crucially, refused to stop.
The subtext is partly about class and permission. Mansfield, a colonial New Zealander who fought her way into the literary world of London modernism, knew how fragile creative legitimacy could feel, especially for a woman expected to be charming rather than ambitious. Calling her early work “twaddle” pre-empts the critics: she will shame herself first, then keep writing anyway. It’s defiance dressed as modesty.
Context matters, too: modernism prized the polished fragment, the perfected short story, the sentence that looks effortless. Mansfield reveals the grubby backstage labor behind that elegance. She doesn’t romanticize the muse; she champions practice, even embarrassing practice. The line quietly rewrites the origin story of talent: not lightning, but accumulation. If you want the Mansfield who can make a room vibrate with a single detail, you have to tolerate the Mansfield who once wrote nonsense - and, crucially, refused to stop.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Katherine
Add to List



