"Love always involves responsibility, and love always involves sacrifice. And we do not really love Christ unless we are prepared to face His task and to take up His Cross"
About this Quote
Barclay refuses to let love stay in the realm of warm feeling or private inspiration. He frames it as a moral contract with teeth: responsibility and sacrifice are not optional add-ons but the very proof that love is real. The cadence matters. By repeating "love always involves..". he builds a kind of pastoral inevitability, closing off the escape hatches modern religion often leaves open - the idea that devotion can be sincere while remaining cost-free.
The subtext is a critique of what we might now call consumer spirituality: a Jesus admired as a teacher, an icon, a source of comfort, without the inconvenience of imitation. Barclay draws a bright line between affection for Christ and allegiance to Christ. "We do not really love" is deliberately destabilizing. It challenges the believer's self-concept, not their theology: you can assent to doctrine and still be, in his terms, loveless.
"His task" and "His Cross" sharpen the demand. The Cross is not only a symbol of personal hardship; in Christian memory it's the public consequence of confronting power, refusing violence, and accepting suffering rather than outsourcing it. Barclay, writing in a 20th-century Britain marked by war, austerity, and social rebuilding, is speaking into a culture where sacrifice was both familiar and contested. He channels a postwar moral seriousness: discipleship is measured less by intensity of belief than by willingness to absorb cost for others.
Intent-wise, the quote is pastoral but prosecutorial. It comforts only by stripping comfort down to something sturdier: love that shows up when it hurts.
The subtext is a critique of what we might now call consumer spirituality: a Jesus admired as a teacher, an icon, a source of comfort, without the inconvenience of imitation. Barclay draws a bright line between affection for Christ and allegiance to Christ. "We do not really love" is deliberately destabilizing. It challenges the believer's self-concept, not their theology: you can assent to doctrine and still be, in his terms, loveless.
"His task" and "His Cross" sharpen the demand. The Cross is not only a symbol of personal hardship; in Christian memory it's the public consequence of confronting power, refusing violence, and accepting suffering rather than outsourcing it. Barclay, writing in a 20th-century Britain marked by war, austerity, and social rebuilding, is speaking into a culture where sacrifice was both familiar and contested. He channels a postwar moral seriousness: discipleship is measured less by intensity of belief than by willingness to absorb cost for others.
Intent-wise, the quote is pastoral but prosecutorial. It comforts only by stripping comfort down to something sturdier: love that shows up when it hurts.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List








