"Love is like the wild rose-briar; Friendship like the holly-tree. The holly is dark when the rose-briar blooms, but which will bloom most constantly?"
About this Quote
Bronte doesn’t flatter love here; she puts it on trial. The image of the wild rose-briar is all impulse and seasonality: beautiful, untamed, and timed to its own brief blaze. It “blooms,” then it’s gone. Friendship, by contrast, gets the holly-tree: evergreen, darker, less showy, built for endurance. The crucial move is that Bronte refuses to rank them by intensity. She ranks them by reliability, and she does it with a question that needles the reader into admitting what they already know but don’t want to say out loud.
The subtext is a critique of romantic glamour. Love arrives with color and drama, the kind of thing people mistake for permanence because it feels like destiny. But Bronte’s “wild” isn’t purely celebratory; it carries a warning about what can’t be domesticated. Friendship looks “dark” beside love’s peak, which captures a cultural bias that still holds: we treat the steady, non-spectacular bond as secondary when passion is in the room. Yet holly’s darkness is also its strength, the shade that survives winter.
Context matters: Bronte writes out of a Victorian milieu that prized romantic plots while policing women’s choices and reputations. In that world, love could be catastrophic, socially and personally, while friendship (especially between women, or within tight communities) functioned as actual infrastructure. The line lands because it’s not anti-love; it’s anti-delusion. It asks what you want your life made of: a blaze you remember, or a green that stays.
The subtext is a critique of romantic glamour. Love arrives with color and drama, the kind of thing people mistake for permanence because it feels like destiny. But Bronte’s “wild” isn’t purely celebratory; it carries a warning about what can’t be domesticated. Friendship looks “dark” beside love’s peak, which captures a cultural bias that still holds: we treat the steady, non-spectacular bond as secondary when passion is in the room. Yet holly’s darkness is also its strength, the shade that survives winter.
Context matters: Bronte writes out of a Victorian milieu that prized romantic plots while policing women’s choices and reputations. In that world, love could be catastrophic, socially and personally, while friendship (especially between women, or within tight communities) functioned as actual infrastructure. The line lands because it’s not anti-love; it’s anti-delusion. It asks what you want your life made of: a blaze you remember, or a green that stays.
Quote Details
| Topic | Friendship |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Emily
Add to List










