"Man, born of woman, has found it a hard thing to forgive her for giving him birth. The patriarchal protest against the ancient matriarch has borne strange fruit through the years"
About this Quote
The subtext is that misogyny often pretends to be about women’s supposed defects, when it’s really about male discomfort with origins. If you can’t tolerate the fact that you began as someone’s helpless product, you build a world that insists you were meant to rule. “The patriarchal protest against the ancient matriarch” frames history as backlash: not the steady march of progress, but a sustained argument against a memory (or myth) of female-centered power. Whether or not one buys literal “ancient matriarchy,” the phrase works as cultural shorthand for the suppressed knowledge that women’s labor - reproductive, domestic, emotional - is foundational.
“Strange fruit” lands with deliberate menace. It’s not just “consequences”; it’s bitter harvest, an American phrase haunted by racial terror. Smith, a Southern writer who anatomized segregation’s moral rot, links gender domination to the broader ecology of violence: once a society learns to rationalize control over the source of life, it gets fluent at rationalizing control over everyone else.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: Man Born of Woman (Lillian Smith, 1941)
Evidence: Man, born of woman, has found it a hard thing to forgive her for giving him birth. The patriarchal protest against the ancient matriarch has borne strange fruit through the years. (pp. 7-17). The strongest primary-source trail I found points to the essay "Man Born of Woman," published in North Georgia Review, vol. VI, nos. 1-4 (Winter 1941), pp. 7-17, credited to Lillian Smith with Paula Snelling. Multiple secondary sources identify that essay as the relevant work, and a bibliographic listing of Smith's works gives the exact citation. I also found later scholarly discussion describing the 1941 essay's themes, which match the quote closely. However, I was not able to access a scanned image of the original 1941 pages directly in the available search results, so the exact quote text here is verified from quotation/reference sites rather than from a page image of the magazine itself. Because of that, I cannot prove from the evidence I accessed whether this sentence first appeared there or was later reprinted in a book such as Killers of the Dream (1949). The best-supported first-publication candidate is the 1941 North Georgia Review essay. Other candidates (1) A Lillian Smith Reader (Lillian Eugenia Smith, 2016) compilation98.9% Lillian Eugenia Smith Margaret Rose Gladney, Lisa ... Man, born of woman, has found it a hard thing to forgive her fo... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Smith, Lillian. (2026, March 17). Man, born of woman, has found it a hard thing to forgive her for giving him birth. The patriarchal protest against the ancient matriarch has borne strange fruit through the years. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/man-born-of-woman-has-found-it-a-hard-thing-to-162640/
Chicago Style
Smith, Lillian. "Man, born of woman, has found it a hard thing to forgive her for giving him birth. The patriarchal protest against the ancient matriarch has borne strange fruit through the years." FixQuotes. March 17, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/man-born-of-woman-has-found-it-a-hard-thing-to-162640/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Man, born of woman, has found it a hard thing to forgive her for giving him birth. The patriarchal protest against the ancient matriarch has borne strange fruit through the years." FixQuotes, 17 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/man-born-of-woman-has-found-it-a-hard-thing-to-162640/. Accessed 17 Mar. 2026.








