"Man makes holy what he believes"
About this Quote
Holiness, for Renan, isn’t a property floating in the universe waiting to be discovered; it’s a human accreditation. “Man makes holy what he believes” lands with the cool audacity of 19th-century secular critique: sacredness is not a lightning bolt from above but a social decision dressed up as metaphysics. The line is compact enough to sound pious, then quietly detonates piety by relocating its source.
Renan’s intent is less to sneer at religion than to anatomize it. A philologist and historian of Christianity, he treated scripture and saints the way a modern journalist treats institutions: as products of time, power, and narrative. The subtext is that belief doesn’t merely accept the holy; it manufactures it. Communities crown certain texts, places, and people with an aura, then defend that aura as if it were self-evident. “Makes” is the operative verb: active, constructive, human. Holiness becomes a kind of cultural technology for creating cohesion, authority, and meaning.
Context matters. Renan wrote in post-Enlightenment France, where the prestige of science and historical criticism collided with the old claims of the Church. His work, including the controversial Life of Jesus, helped normalize the idea that religion could be studied as history rather than received as revelation. That era’s anxiety - if the sacred is made, can it be unmade? - hums behind the sentence.
The quote still works because it’s a mirror, not a verdict. It implicates everyone who treats their commitments as untouchable: faith, nation, ideology, even celebrity. Renan’s point is bracingly modern: the holy is a human vote that people forget they cast.
Renan’s intent is less to sneer at religion than to anatomize it. A philologist and historian of Christianity, he treated scripture and saints the way a modern journalist treats institutions: as products of time, power, and narrative. The subtext is that belief doesn’t merely accept the holy; it manufactures it. Communities crown certain texts, places, and people with an aura, then defend that aura as if it were self-evident. “Makes” is the operative verb: active, constructive, human. Holiness becomes a kind of cultural technology for creating cohesion, authority, and meaning.
Context matters. Renan wrote in post-Enlightenment France, where the prestige of science and historical criticism collided with the old claims of the Church. His work, including the controversial Life of Jesus, helped normalize the idea that religion could be studied as history rather than received as revelation. That era’s anxiety - if the sacred is made, can it be unmade? - hums behind the sentence.
The quote still works because it’s a mirror, not a verdict. It implicates everyone who treats their commitments as untouchable: faith, nation, ideology, even celebrity. Renan’s point is bracingly modern: the holy is a human vote that people forget they cast.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Ernest
Add to List









