"Man's capacity for justice makes democracy possible, but man's inclination to injustice makes democracy necessary"
About this Quote
Niebuhr rigs this sentence like a moral booby trap: democracy survives on our best instincts, yet exists because those instincts are unreliable. The line turns on a stark symmetry - capacity versus inclination - that refuses comforting stories about political progress. He’s not praising democracy as the natural expression of human goodness; he’s treating it as a containment system built for a species that can glimpse fairness and still reach for advantage.
The specific intent is to dislodge naive idealism on both ends. Against utopians, Niebuhr insists that injustice isn’t an accident that education will erase; it’s a recurring temptation, amplified by power. Against cynics, he insists we do possess a real, if limited, aptitude for justice - enough to justify shared rule and moral argument rather than pure coercion. Democracy becomes a wager that imperfect people can check one another’s worst impulses while still appealing to one another’s better ones.
The subtext is theological without being sectarian: human beings are marked by a kind of moral crookedness (original sin, in Niebuhr’s orbit), especially in groups. That’s why he distrusted sentimental pacifism and any politics that assumed virtue at scale. Written in the shadow of the Great Depression, rising fascism, and later the Cold War, the line reads like a warning label on modernity: concentrated power will rationalize itself, even when it speaks the language of righteousness.
What makes it work is its cold consolation. Democracy isn’t holy. It’s necessary. And necessity, for Niebuhr, is the adult version of hope.
The specific intent is to dislodge naive idealism on both ends. Against utopians, Niebuhr insists that injustice isn’t an accident that education will erase; it’s a recurring temptation, amplified by power. Against cynics, he insists we do possess a real, if limited, aptitude for justice - enough to justify shared rule and moral argument rather than pure coercion. Democracy becomes a wager that imperfect people can check one another’s worst impulses while still appealing to one another’s better ones.
The subtext is theological without being sectarian: human beings are marked by a kind of moral crookedness (original sin, in Niebuhr’s orbit), especially in groups. That’s why he distrusted sentimental pacifism and any politics that assumed virtue at scale. Written in the shadow of the Great Depression, rising fascism, and later the Cold War, the line reads like a warning label on modernity: concentrated power will rationalize itself, even when it speaks the language of righteousness.
What makes it work is its cold consolation. Democracy isn’t holy. It’s necessary. And necessity, for Niebuhr, is the adult version of hope.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Reinhold
Add to List
