"Many a man in love with a dimple makes the mistake of marrying the whole girl"
About this Quote
Leacock’s line lands like a parlor joke and stays like an indictment. It takes the sugary cliché of “falling in love” and exposes the accounting error inside it: confusing a detail with a destiny. A dimple is nothing - a minor facial accident - yet in romance it becomes a symbol people inflate into proof of character, compatibility, fate. The comedy comes from the brutal arithmetic of “the whole girl,” a phrase that makes marriage sound like a bulk purchase. As an economist by training, Leacock frames desire as misallocated investment: one charming feature is overvalued, the rest of the reality sheet ignored until after the contract is signed.
The subtext isn’t simply “don’t be shallow.” It’s sharper: modern courtship encourages fetishizing fragments. We fall for a trait, a vibe, a curated anecdote, then retrofit a person around it. Leacock’s “mistake” is not moral failure; it’s cognitive bias dressed up as romance - projection, confirmation, the thrill of a small, legible signal over a complicated human being.
Context matters. Writing in an era when marriage was more binding, more gendered, and harder to exit without scandal, the joke carries consequence. The punchline depends on a social reality where “marrying” is irreversible enough to warrant dark humor. And yes, the line reveals its time: “the whole girl” reads possessive, as if the woman is a unit acquired. That dated phrasing is part of the point, too. Leacock is mocking the consumer logic of love even as he can’t fully step outside it.
The subtext isn’t simply “don’t be shallow.” It’s sharper: modern courtship encourages fetishizing fragments. We fall for a trait, a vibe, a curated anecdote, then retrofit a person around it. Leacock’s “mistake” is not moral failure; it’s cognitive bias dressed up as romance - projection, confirmation, the thrill of a small, legible signal over a complicated human being.
Context matters. Writing in an era when marriage was more binding, more gendered, and harder to exit without scandal, the joke carries consequence. The punchline depends on a social reality where “marrying” is irreversible enough to warrant dark humor. And yes, the line reveals its time: “the whole girl” reads possessive, as if the woman is a unit acquired. That dated phrasing is part of the point, too. Leacock is mocking the consumer logic of love even as he can’t fully step outside it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Love |
|---|
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List






