"May we so love as never to have occasion to repent of our love!"
About this Quote
Thoreau’s line lands like a prayer, but it’s really a challenge disguised as benediction. “May we” frames love as a communal aspiration rather than a private feeling, and that matters coming from a writer who kept insisting that the most personal choices are moral choices. The syntax has the cadence of a sermon, yet the content is strikingly unsentimental: love isn’t validated by intensity, but by what it leaves behind. The standard romantic script promises no regrets; Thoreau sharpens it into a test. Love that demands later repentance wasn’t “too real” or “too messy.” It was mis-aimed.
The subtext is classic Thoreau: suspicion of attachment that compromises integrity. He admired closeness, but he distrusted dependence, and he had little patience for emotional surrender that dulled judgment. “Occasion to repent” implies consequences, not just embarrassment. Repentance is ethical language, the vocabulary of having violated one’s own principles. So the plea is not for safer love, but for clearer love: love chosen with attention, restraint, and self-respect, love that doesn’t require you to bargain away your conscience and call it devotion.
Contextually, this sits in the 19th-century American churn of Protestant moral seriousness and Transcendentalist faith in the self’s inner law. Thoreau isn’t urging people to love less; he’s urging them to love in a way that can survive daylight, time, and solitude. The line works because it refuses to flatter the reader. It assumes love can be wrong, and insists we’re responsible for getting it right.
The subtext is classic Thoreau: suspicion of attachment that compromises integrity. He admired closeness, but he distrusted dependence, and he had little patience for emotional surrender that dulled judgment. “Occasion to repent” implies consequences, not just embarrassment. Repentance is ethical language, the vocabulary of having violated one’s own principles. So the plea is not for safer love, but for clearer love: love chosen with attention, restraint, and self-respect, love that doesn’t require you to bargain away your conscience and call it devotion.
Contextually, this sits in the 19th-century American churn of Protestant moral seriousness and Transcendentalist faith in the self’s inner law. Thoreau isn’t urging people to love less; he’s urging them to love in a way that can survive daylight, time, and solitude. The line works because it refuses to flatter the reader. It assumes love can be wrong, and insists we’re responsible for getting it right.
Quote Details
| Topic | Love |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List






