"Men are more moral than they think and far more immoral than they can imagine"
About this Quote
Freud’s line works because it flatters and insults in the same breath, a neat psychological trap that leaves the reader nodding before realizing they’ve been indicted. “More moral than they think” nods to the ordinary person’s self-disgust and private guilt; we suspect we’re worse than we are. Then Freud yanks the rug: you’re not nearly imaginative enough about your own capacity for cruelty, selfishness, and desire. The sentence is built like a diagnosis, not a proverb. It doesn’t invite self-improvement so much as it punctures the comforting story that conscience is the whole self.
The intent is classic Freud: destabilize the idea of a transparent, rational “I.” Morality isn’t just a conscious code you choose; it’s also habit, social training, fear of punishment, love for others, and the internal cop we now call the superego. So yes, people often behave decently without giving themselves credit. But the second clause is the real payload: the unconscious is not a gentle basement. It’s stocked with impulses we disown because they’re incompatible with our self-image. That’s why “can imagine” matters: the limit isn’t immorality, it’s our mental censorship.
Contextually, this is Freud’s broader quarrel with bourgeois self-certainty in early 20th-century Europe, a culture that prized civility while generating war, repression, and scapegoating. He’s warning that public respectability and private darkness aren’t opposites; they’re collaborators. The line survives because it still describes modern life: curated virtue on the surface, algorithmically amplified appetites underneath, and a persistent belief that the real danger is “them,” not the parts of ourselves we refuse to picture.
The intent is classic Freud: destabilize the idea of a transparent, rational “I.” Morality isn’t just a conscious code you choose; it’s also habit, social training, fear of punishment, love for others, and the internal cop we now call the superego. So yes, people often behave decently without giving themselves credit. But the second clause is the real payload: the unconscious is not a gentle basement. It’s stocked with impulses we disown because they’re incompatible with our self-image. That’s why “can imagine” matters: the limit isn’t immorality, it’s our mental censorship.
Contextually, this is Freud’s broader quarrel with bourgeois self-certainty in early 20th-century Europe, a culture that prized civility while generating war, repression, and scapegoating. He’s warning that public respectability and private darkness aren’t opposites; they’re collaborators. The line survives because it still describes modern life: curated virtue on the surface, algorithmically amplified appetites underneath, and a persistent belief that the real danger is “them,” not the parts of ourselves we refuse to picture.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Sigmund
Add to List






