"Mercury pollution from power plants is a national problem that requires a national response"
About this Quote
“Mercury pollution from power plants is a national problem that requires a national response” is policy-speak with a deliberate moral edge. Tom Allen isn’t just naming a contaminant; he’s drawing a jurisdictional boundary line. Mercury doesn’t respect state borders, and neither does the political fallout from poisoned waterways, fish advisories, and the slow, hard-to-photograph damage to children’s neurological development. The sentence turns that messy reality into a clean argument for federal authority.
The intent is strategic: preempt the classic dodge that environmental regulation should be “local control.” By framing mercury as “national,” Allen recasts regulation not as bureaucratic overreach but as basic competence. Power plants are often concentrated in some regions while the deposition and health costs spread widely; the subtext is a fairness claim. States shouldn’t have to compete by weakening standards, and downwind communities shouldn’t be forced to absorb someone else’s cheap electricity.
Context matters here. Allen, a Maine Democrat known for environmental priorities, was speaking in an era when mercury rules were being fought over in Washington, especially around the Bush administration’s attempts to soften or marketize controls. “National response” signals suspicion of patchwork fixes, voluntary measures, or cap-and-trade schemes that could legalize hot spots. It’s a tidy line built for hearings and headlines: identify the villain (pollution), scale it up (national), then demand the only actor big enough to act (the federal government).
The intent is strategic: preempt the classic dodge that environmental regulation should be “local control.” By framing mercury as “national,” Allen recasts regulation not as bureaucratic overreach but as basic competence. Power plants are often concentrated in some regions while the deposition and health costs spread widely; the subtext is a fairness claim. States shouldn’t have to compete by weakening standards, and downwind communities shouldn’t be forced to absorb someone else’s cheap electricity.
Context matters here. Allen, a Maine Democrat known for environmental priorities, was speaking in an era when mercury rules were being fought over in Washington, especially around the Bush administration’s attempts to soften or marketize controls. “National response” signals suspicion of patchwork fixes, voluntary measures, or cap-and-trade schemes that could legalize hot spots. It’s a tidy line built for hearings and headlines: identify the villain (pollution), scale it up (national), then demand the only actor big enough to act (the federal government).
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Tom
Add to List




