"Mmm, I love Yoda. I didn't like Jar Jar Binks though, he was all wrong"
About this Quote
Pop culture opinions rarely arrive this bluntly, and that is the point. Gail Porter’s “Mmm, I love Yoda” opens with a deliberately unguarded, almost tactile pleasure: not a thesis, a vibe. The little “Mmm” matters. It signals fandom as appetite, not scholarship, the kind of casual intimacy that’s shaped modern celebrity talk-show culture where taste is performed in real time and the audience is invited to nod along.
Then comes the snap: “I didn’t like Jar Jar Binks though.” The sentence turns on “though,” the tiny hinge that sets up a clean binary between what Star Wars fans often treat as sacred (original-trilogy gravitas, practical effects, archetypal wisdom) and what they’ve historically punished (a comic sidekick read as childish, grating, and corporate). Porter isn’t offering a nuanced film critique; she’s aligning herself with a widely shared emotional consensus. That’s savvy: it’s safer, funnier, and more legible than saying something complicated about prequel-era tonal shifts.
“He was all wrong” is wonderfully imprecise, a phrase that communicates certainty without evidence. Subtext: I don’t need receipts; you already know what I mean. In celebrity speech, that kind of shorthand is currency. It bonds speaker and audience through recognition, not argument, while smuggling in a larger cultural judgment: some characters feel like they belong to a story’s DNA, and others feel like market research wearing a costume.
Then comes the snap: “I didn’t like Jar Jar Binks though.” The sentence turns on “though,” the tiny hinge that sets up a clean binary between what Star Wars fans often treat as sacred (original-trilogy gravitas, practical effects, archetypal wisdom) and what they’ve historically punished (a comic sidekick read as childish, grating, and corporate). Porter isn’t offering a nuanced film critique; she’s aligning herself with a widely shared emotional consensus. That’s savvy: it’s safer, funnier, and more legible than saying something complicated about prequel-era tonal shifts.
“He was all wrong” is wonderfully imprecise, a phrase that communicates certainty without evidence. Subtext: I don’t need receipts; you already know what I mean. In celebrity speech, that kind of shorthand is currency. It bonds speaker and audience through recognition, not argument, while smuggling in a larger cultural judgment: some characters feel like they belong to a story’s DNA, and others feel like market research wearing a costume.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Gail
Add to List







