"Most of the results of using technical bugging devices were of little importance for my service. It may have been different in counter-intelligence, where bugs in flats, etc., were used to obtain a lot of information about what counter-intelligence was interested in"
About this Quote
Markus Wolf’s genius here is bureaucratic understatement deployed as camouflage. “Of little importance” reads like a bored memo line, the kind you’d skim in a quarterly report. But coming from the longtime spymaster of East Germany’s foreign intelligence, the phrasing is doing tactical work: it narrows responsibility, laundered through procedural language. Bugging happened, sure, but it was mostly noise. Any real intrusion? That was someone else’s department.
The quote is a miniature lesson in how security states defend themselves after the fact. Wolf draws a neat boundary between his “service” and “counter-intelligence,” as if apparatuses that share a government, a mission, and often a target can be cleanly separated by org chart. The subtext is exculpatory: foreign intelligence might be roguish but professional; domestic surveillance is where the ugly, intimate violations supposedly live. “Flats, etc.” is especially telling. The “etc.” is a shrug over the human reality of listening in on bedrooms, arguments, fear, and private dissent. The euphemism turns a lived space into a technical category.
Context sharpens the cynicism. After the Cold War, Wolf cultivated an image of the refined, pragmatic intelligence chief, distinct from the Stasi’s pervasive domestic terror. This line participates in that rehabilitation, recasting invasive technology as marginal, even disappointing, except when turned inward. It’s not a confession. It’s an accounting trick: minimize the yield, relocate the blame, and let the machinery remain nameless.
The quote is a miniature lesson in how security states defend themselves after the fact. Wolf draws a neat boundary between his “service” and “counter-intelligence,” as if apparatuses that share a government, a mission, and often a target can be cleanly separated by org chart. The subtext is exculpatory: foreign intelligence might be roguish but professional; domestic surveillance is where the ugly, intimate violations supposedly live. “Flats, etc.” is especially telling. The “etc.” is a shrug over the human reality of listening in on bedrooms, arguments, fear, and private dissent. The euphemism turns a lived space into a technical category.
Context sharpens the cynicism. After the Cold War, Wolf cultivated an image of the refined, pragmatic intelligence chief, distinct from the Stasi’s pervasive domestic terror. This line participates in that rehabilitation, recasting invasive technology as marginal, even disappointing, except when turned inward. It’s not a confession. It’s an accounting trick: minimize the yield, relocate the blame, and let the machinery remain nameless.
Quote Details
| Topic | Privacy & Cybersecurity |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Markus
Add to List



