"Most people who ask for advice from others have already resolved to act as it pleases them"
About this Quote
Advice, in Gibran's hands, becomes less a searchlight than a prop: something we pick up to steady the story we already plan to tell. The line cuts against the flattering myth that we seek counsel to be changed. Instead, it suggests we seek it to be confirmed, forgiven, or at least witnessed.
The intent is quietly corrective. Gibran isn’t mocking vulnerability so much as naming a common social maneuver: outsourcing responsibility while keeping the steering wheel. Asking for advice can function as a moral alibi. If things go well, we were wise enough to consult. If things go poorly, we can blame the counsel we never truly followed. The subtext is a critique of performative humility, that soft pose of openness that hides a closed decision.
It works because it pivots on the phrase "as it pleases them". Pleasure here isn’t hedonism; it’s self-soothing. We follow the path that preserves our identity, our pride, our preferred version of events. Advice threatens that narrative, so we sample it like a menu, choosing what matches the appetite we arrived with.
Context matters: Gibran wrote as a poet-philosopher in an era when public wisdom literature and spiritual counsel had cultural cachet. His aphoristic style aims for moral clarity with a humane edge. Read today, the line lands even harder in a culture of endless hot takes and crowd-sourced validation, where "seeking advice" often means polling for permission.
The intent is quietly corrective. Gibran isn’t mocking vulnerability so much as naming a common social maneuver: outsourcing responsibility while keeping the steering wheel. Asking for advice can function as a moral alibi. If things go well, we were wise enough to consult. If things go poorly, we can blame the counsel we never truly followed. The subtext is a critique of performative humility, that soft pose of openness that hides a closed decision.
It works because it pivots on the phrase "as it pleases them". Pleasure here isn’t hedonism; it’s self-soothing. We follow the path that preserves our identity, our pride, our preferred version of events. Advice threatens that narrative, so we sample it like a menu, choosing what matches the appetite we arrived with.
Context matters: Gibran wrote as a poet-philosopher in an era when public wisdom literature and spiritual counsel had cultural cachet. His aphoristic style aims for moral clarity with a humane edge. Read today, the line lands even harder in a culture of endless hot takes and crowd-sourced validation, where "seeking advice" often means polling for permission.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Kahlil
Add to List











