"Mr. Darwin refers to the multitude of the individual of every species, which, from one cause or another, perish either before, or soon after attaining maturity"
About this Quote
Owen’s prose is doing the quiet work of containment. By quoting Darwin on the “multitude” that perish “before, or soon after attaining maturity,” he’s not merely summarizing a biological observation; he’s spotlighting the grim arithmetic that makes natural selection go. Victorian readers were steeped in a moralized view of nature - providential, balanced, implicitly humane. Owen drags them toward a colder ledger: life produces excess, and death is the default outcome.
The phrasing matters. “From one cause or another” looks casual, almost bureaucratic, flattening famine, predation, disease, and accident into an interchangeable list. That rhetorical shrug is strategic. It naturalizes mass mortality as routine rather than scandalous, which is exactly what Darwin’s theory needed to be persuasive: selection only “selects” because most organisms never make it to reproduction. Owen’s sentence turns survival into an exception without sounding like a manifesto.
Context sharpens the subtext. Owen was a formidable anatomist and a complicated figure in the Darwinian drama - an establishment scientist who engaged with evolutionary ideas while also defending his own intellectual territory. Citing Darwin here reads like calibrated acknowledgment: he grants the empirical premise (overproduction and early death) while keeping a measured, distancing tone (“Mr. Darwin refers…”). It’s recognition without surrender, an attempt to frame Darwin as one voice in a broader scientific conversation that Owen still hopes to referee.
The intent, then, isn’t lyrical. It’s surgical: isolate the brutal premise, sanitize its shock, and keep control of how revolutionary biology gets introduced to polite society.
The phrasing matters. “From one cause or another” looks casual, almost bureaucratic, flattening famine, predation, disease, and accident into an interchangeable list. That rhetorical shrug is strategic. It naturalizes mass mortality as routine rather than scandalous, which is exactly what Darwin’s theory needed to be persuasive: selection only “selects” because most organisms never make it to reproduction. Owen’s sentence turns survival into an exception without sounding like a manifesto.
Context sharpens the subtext. Owen was a formidable anatomist and a complicated figure in the Darwinian drama - an establishment scientist who engaged with evolutionary ideas while also defending his own intellectual territory. Citing Darwin here reads like calibrated acknowledgment: he grants the empirical premise (overproduction and early death) while keeping a measured, distancing tone (“Mr. Darwin refers…”). It’s recognition without surrender, an attempt to frame Darwin as one voice in a broader scientific conversation that Owen still hopes to referee.
The intent, then, isn’t lyrical. It’s surgical: isolate the brutal premise, sanitize its shock, and keep control of how revolutionary biology gets introduced to polite society.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List

