"Mr. Tennyson has said that more things are wrought by prayer than this world dreams of, but he wisely refrains from saying whether they are good or bad things"
About this Quote
Butler takes Tennyson's pious flourish and slips a blade into the velvet. The original line from "The Passing of Arthur" flatters prayer as a kind of unseen technology: quiet words that move the machinery of fate. Butler doesn't deny the possibility. He denies the assumption. Yes, prayer may "wrought" more than the world suspects, but the world also has a talent for mistaking impact for virtue. His compliment to Tennyson - "wisely refrains" - is pure dry British acid: the wisdom is not spiritual humility so much as strategic vagueness. If you won't name outcomes, you can't be held responsible for them.
The subtext is an indictment of moral outsourcing. Prayer is often sold as inherently benevolent because it feels benevolent: it's private, earnest, nonviolent. Butler reminds you that causality isn't automatically ethical. A prayer can be a wish in costume, a polite form of coercion, a sanctified way of asking the universe to take your side. When competing prayers collide, "more things" get wrought - wars justified, hierarchies preserved, guilt laundered - and the halo stays intact because the method is intangible.
Context matters: Butler is a Victorian skeptic who made a career of puncturing respectable certainties (religion, progress narratives, complacent moralism). His line reads like a footnote that turns into a verdict. It's not atheism so much as accountability: if prayer is power, it deserves the same scrutiny we give any other power, especially when it's granted immunity by good intentions.
The subtext is an indictment of moral outsourcing. Prayer is often sold as inherently benevolent because it feels benevolent: it's private, earnest, nonviolent. Butler reminds you that causality isn't automatically ethical. A prayer can be a wish in costume, a polite form of coercion, a sanctified way of asking the universe to take your side. When competing prayers collide, "more things" get wrought - wars justified, hierarchies preserved, guilt laundered - and the halo stays intact because the method is intangible.
Context matters: Butler is a Victorian skeptic who made a career of puncturing respectable certainties (religion, progress narratives, complacent moralism). His line reads like a footnote that turns into a verdict. It's not atheism so much as accountability: if prayer is power, it deserves the same scrutiny we give any other power, especially when it's granted immunity by good intentions.
Quote Details
| Topic | Prayer |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List
