"Music at times is more like perfume than mathematics"
About this Quote
Marcel’s line slips a knife into the modern obsession with explanation. To call music “more like perfume than mathematics” is to resist the prestige of systems: the idea that what matters most is what can be counted, formalized, proved. Perfume isn’t anti-intellectual; it’s anti-possessive. You can’t hold it still long enough to diagram it. It announces itself, alters the room, then changes as you try to name it. That’s Marcel’s point about music: its power arrives as atmosphere and presence, not as an argument that submits to step-by-step verification.
The comparison also smuggles in a critique of the listener. Mathematics invites mastery; perfume invites attention. With perfume you don’t “solve” anything, you notice how it clings to memory, how it pulls private associations into public space. Music works the same way: it reaches the body first, meaning second, and the meaning is often inseparable from the conditions of encounter (where you are, who you’re with, what you’ve lost). Marcel, an existentialist with a Christian inflection, is wary of treating human experience as an object. He’s defending mystery as a category: not ignorance to be remedied, but depth to be lived.
Contextually, this lands as a mid-century rebuke to rationalist confidence and technocratic tidiness. Marcel isn’t denying structure in music; he’s warning that structure is not the event. The most honest way to talk about music may be to admit its volatility: it permeates, it haunts, it refuses to be reduced without being diminished.
The comparison also smuggles in a critique of the listener. Mathematics invites mastery; perfume invites attention. With perfume you don’t “solve” anything, you notice how it clings to memory, how it pulls private associations into public space. Music works the same way: it reaches the body first, meaning second, and the meaning is often inseparable from the conditions of encounter (where you are, who you’re with, what you’ve lost). Marcel, an existentialist with a Christian inflection, is wary of treating human experience as an object. He’s defending mystery as a category: not ignorance to be remedied, but depth to be lived.
Contextually, this lands as a mid-century rebuke to rationalist confidence and technocratic tidiness. Marcel isn’t denying structure in music; he’s warning that structure is not the event. The most honest way to talk about music may be to admit its volatility: it permeates, it haunts, it refuses to be reduced without being diminished.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Gabriel
Add to List



