"Music is like making love: either all or nothing"
About this Quote
Stern’s line lands with the blunt authority of someone who spent a lifetime watching people try to “play it safe” onstage. “Music is like making love” isn’t a cute comparison; it’s a demand for total presence. He picks the most charged, bodily, reputation-risking human act he can name, then strips it down to a binary: all or nothing. That hard edge is the point. In performance, half-commitment reads as politeness, not artistry. It’s technically competent, emotionally absent, and audiences can feel the vacancy in real time.
The subtext is a warning against the temptations of control. Classical musicians are trained to minimize error, to respect the score, to behave. Stern, famously unsentimental about empty virtuosity, is arguing that fidelity without vulnerability is its own kind of betrayal. “All” means surrendering to phrasing, timing, and dynamic risk even when it might crack; “nothing” is the bloodless execution that protects the ego but forfeits the encounter.
There’s also an old-world, midcentury masculinity baked into the metaphor: erotic mastery as a model for artistic mastery. Today that can read as swagger, even a little cringe, but the cultural logic remains legible: intimacy can’t be faked. Coming from a violinist who championed live performance and human warmth over studio polish, the quote is a manifesto against the era’s creeping professionalization. Stern isn’t romanticizing music; he’s insisting it’s an exchange. If you’re not willing to be exposed, don’t ask the audience to meet you there.
The subtext is a warning against the temptations of control. Classical musicians are trained to minimize error, to respect the score, to behave. Stern, famously unsentimental about empty virtuosity, is arguing that fidelity without vulnerability is its own kind of betrayal. “All” means surrendering to phrasing, timing, and dynamic risk even when it might crack; “nothing” is the bloodless execution that protects the ego but forfeits the encounter.
There’s also an old-world, midcentury masculinity baked into the metaphor: erotic mastery as a model for artistic mastery. Today that can read as swagger, even a little cringe, but the cultural logic remains legible: intimacy can’t be faked. Coming from a violinist who championed live performance and human warmth over studio polish, the quote is a manifesto against the era’s creeping professionalization. Stern isn’t romanticizing music; he’s insisting it’s an exchange. If you’re not willing to be exposed, don’t ask the audience to meet you there.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Isaac
Add to List





