Skip to main content

Time & Perspective Quote by Harrison Birtwistle

"Music is such a problem in the time it takes"

About this Quote

Music, for Birtwistle, isn’t a soothing substance that pours neatly into minutes; it’s a stubborn engineering puzzle that only exists while it’s happening. “Such a problem” is deliberately anti-romantic: the composer as a kind of unsentimental technician wrestling with duration itself. And “in the time it takes” is the quiet twist of the knife. Music doesn’t merely occur in time the way a painting hangs in space; it consumes time, demands it, and keeps re-defining what that time feels like as it passes.

The line sits squarely in Birtwistle’s wider aesthetic: modernist, myth-haunted, often abrasive, suspicious of easy narrative payoff. His works frequently treat musical events like blocks, rituals, collisions - less melody you can hum than structures you endure and navigate. In that world, time isn’t a neutral container; it’s the main material. The “problem” is how to make thirty seconds feel like an eternity, or an hour feel like a single, inexorable gesture, without relying on the comforting grammar of conventional tonal progression.

There’s subtext, too, about listening culture. Audiences want music to be instantly legible, to behave like content. Birtwistle suggests the opposite: music is hard precisely because it can’t be skimmed. It won’t sit still for the listener’s habits. It asks for a submission to its pacing, its delays, its sudden recalibrations. The composer’s job, then, isn’t to decorate time but to argue with it - and win, for as long as the piece can hold.

Quote Details

TopicMusic
More Quotes by Harrison Add to List
Birtwistle on Music and Time
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

United Kingdom Flag

Harrison Birtwistle (born July 15, 1934) is a Composer from United Kingdom.

27 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Bob Geldof, Actor
Bob Geldof
Peter Weir, Director