"Musicians now find themselves in the unlikely position of being legitimate. At least the IRS thinks so"
About this Quote
Being “legitimate” is supposed to be the prize: proof you made it, proof you’re not just a barroom act with a tip jar and a dream. Billy Joel flips that victory into a punchline by letting the IRS deliver the compliment. It’s funny because it’s backwards. The state doesn’t validate your art; it validates your taxable income. In Joel’s framing, legitimacy isn’t a cultural honor, it’s a paper trail.
The line lands in the cultural shift where rock musicians stopped being treated as lovable troublemakers and started being treated as an industry: corporations, contracts, tours with payroll, and yes, audits. Joel came up in an era when “musician” still carried a whiff of unseriousness - a job your parents hoped you’d outgrow. By the time you’re successful enough for the IRS to pay attention, you’ve crossed an invisible threshold: you’re no longer an outsider performing at society; you’re a participant in its bureaucracy.
The subtext is a weary, street-smart kind of self-awareness. Joel isn’t begging for respect from critics or institutions; he’s pointing out that respect arrives through the least romantic channel imaginable. The joke also smuggles in a quiet complaint: once you’re “legitimate,” you inherit the same grinding obligations as everyone else, except your income is stranger, spikier, and easier to misunderstand.
It’s classic Joel - working-class realism with a grin. The punchline isn’t just about taxes. It’s about the cost of being taken seriously.
The line lands in the cultural shift where rock musicians stopped being treated as lovable troublemakers and started being treated as an industry: corporations, contracts, tours with payroll, and yes, audits. Joel came up in an era when “musician” still carried a whiff of unseriousness - a job your parents hoped you’d outgrow. By the time you’re successful enough for the IRS to pay attention, you’ve crossed an invisible threshold: you’re no longer an outsider performing at society; you’re a participant in its bureaucracy.
The subtext is a weary, street-smart kind of self-awareness. Joel isn’t begging for respect from critics or institutions; he’s pointing out that respect arrives through the least romantic channel imaginable. The joke also smuggles in a quiet complaint: once you’re “legitimate,” you inherit the same grinding obligations as everyone else, except your income is stranger, spikier, and easier to misunderstand.
It’s classic Joel - working-class realism with a grin. The punchline isn’t just about taxes. It’s about the cost of being taken seriously.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Billy
Add to List
