"My argument is that War makes rattling good history; but Peace is poor reading"
About this Quote
War is the novelist's cheat code: it injects stakes, motion, and irreversible consequence into the page. Hardy's line lands because it admits, with a wince, the ugly incentive baked into storytelling. "Rattling good history" doesn't just mean exciting chronicles; it suggests a kind of narrative percussion, the loud, legible beat of battles and regime changes that makes the past feel like plot. Peace, by contrast, becomes "poor reading" not because it's worthless, but because its virtues are incremental, quiet, and hard to dramatize without sounding sentimental or dutiful.
Hardy is writing from a century that industrialized both war and news. The Victorian appetite for empire and dispatches, later followed by the Great War's mechanized slaughter, created a public trained to consume catastrophe as narrative. As a novelist obsessed with fate, social constraint, and the slow violence of convention, Hardy knows that "peace" can still be brutal - just not spectacular. His own Wessex tragedies thrive on the pressures of ordinary life; yet he concedes that the market, and maybe the human brain, reads rupture more readily than continuity.
The subtext is self-incriminating. Hardy isn't praising war; he's diagnosing a culture that rewards it with attention, coherence, even meaning. The sentence is a moral complaint disguised as a craft note: if we only call history "good" when it rattles, we're complicit in preferring noise to repair, trauma to maintenance.
Hardy is writing from a century that industrialized both war and news. The Victorian appetite for empire and dispatches, later followed by the Great War's mechanized slaughter, created a public trained to consume catastrophe as narrative. As a novelist obsessed with fate, social constraint, and the slow violence of convention, Hardy knows that "peace" can still be brutal - just not spectacular. His own Wessex tragedies thrive on the pressures of ordinary life; yet he concedes that the market, and maybe the human brain, reads rupture more readily than continuity.
The subtext is self-incriminating. Hardy isn't praising war; he's diagnosing a culture that rewards it with attention, coherence, even meaning. The sentence is a moral complaint disguised as a craft note: if we only call history "good" when it rattles, we're complicit in preferring noise to repair, trauma to maintenance.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List
