"My idea of Hell is to be young again"
About this Quote
Hell, for Piercy, isn’t fire and brimstone. It’s reruns. “My idea of Hell is to be young again” flips the usual nostalgia script, where youth is treated like the one currency that never devalues. Piercy’s line is a refusal to romanticize early life as some pure, uncomplicated Eden. It lands because it’s bluntly heretical in a culture that sells “young” as both aspiration and alibi.
The intent is less shock than correction: youth is often when you’re least equipped to steer your own life. You have the sharpest appetites, the fewest resources, the most social surveillance. Being young can mean living inside other people’s definitions of you, with stakes that feel enormous and choices that are actually narrow. Piercy, a writer shaped by feminist politics and a long view of power, is pointing to the asymmetry: youth is celebrated precisely because it’s more pliable, more marketable, more controllable.
The subtext carries a hard-won relief. To prefer aging is to prefer accumulated agency: the right to say no, the ability to recognize patterns, the muscle memory of surviving mistakes. It also hints at the quiet violences of youth - the body as battleground, the pressure to be desirable, the constant auditioning for approval. Hell is not being young, exactly; it’s being forced to relive the vulnerability without the promise that it gets better.
In a literary context, it’s a compact anti-memoir. Instead of polishing the past into myth, Piercy uses a single sentence to insist that experience counts - and that the future shouldn’t be held hostage by a fetish for beginnings.
The intent is less shock than correction: youth is often when you’re least equipped to steer your own life. You have the sharpest appetites, the fewest resources, the most social surveillance. Being young can mean living inside other people’s definitions of you, with stakes that feel enormous and choices that are actually narrow. Piercy, a writer shaped by feminist politics and a long view of power, is pointing to the asymmetry: youth is celebrated precisely because it’s more pliable, more marketable, more controllable.
The subtext carries a hard-won relief. To prefer aging is to prefer accumulated agency: the right to say no, the ability to recognize patterns, the muscle memory of surviving mistakes. It also hints at the quiet violences of youth - the body as battleground, the pressure to be desirable, the constant auditioning for approval. Hell is not being young, exactly; it’s being forced to relive the vulnerability without the promise that it gets better.
In a literary context, it’s a compact anti-memoir. Instead of polishing the past into myth, Piercy uses a single sentence to insist that experience counts - and that the future shouldn’t be held hostage by a fetish for beginnings.
Quote Details
| Topic | Aging |
|---|
More Quotes by Marge
Add to List
