"My job is to interpret the law based on how the legislature and the court has done it and then, of course, to use our system of justice to develop some new legal tools and new concepts"
About this Quote
There is a delicious tension in Bill Scott positioning himself as both a faithful translator and an innovator: first, “interpret the law based on how the legislature and the court has done it,” then “develop some new legal tools and new concepts.” It’s the tightrope every institutional professional walks, but coming from an actor it reads like an unexpectedly clear-eyed sketch of how power actually moves in America: by honoring precedent loudly while quietly reinventing the machinery underneath.
The phrasing does a lot of work. “My job” sounds dutiful, almost bureaucratic, a way of borrowing legitimacy from the language of public service. “Interpret” is the key verb: it’s what judges do, but it’s also what actors do. Scott smuggles performance into governance without naming it. Interpretation isn’t neutral; it’s a choice about emphasis, framing, and what gets left unsaid. The second clause, introduced with a casual “of course,” normalizes creativity inside a system that claims to be rule-bound. That “of course” is the tell: innovation isn’t an exception, it’s the routine.
Context matters, too. Mid-20th-century America watched courts and legislatures remake daily life through civil rights rulings, expanding administrative states, and evolving criminal procedure. The public story was stability and order; the backstage reality was constant adaptation. Scott’s line captures that cultural contradiction: the law sells itself as settled, but it survives by improvising. Coming from an actor, it doubles as a wink: even justice needs writers’ rooms.
The phrasing does a lot of work. “My job” sounds dutiful, almost bureaucratic, a way of borrowing legitimacy from the language of public service. “Interpret” is the key verb: it’s what judges do, but it’s also what actors do. Scott smuggles performance into governance without naming it. Interpretation isn’t neutral; it’s a choice about emphasis, framing, and what gets left unsaid. The second clause, introduced with a casual “of course,” normalizes creativity inside a system that claims to be rule-bound. That “of course” is the tell: innovation isn’t an exception, it’s the routine.
Context matters, too. Mid-20th-century America watched courts and legislatures remake daily life through civil rights rulings, expanding administrative states, and evolving criminal procedure. The public story was stability and order; the backstage reality was constant adaptation. Scott’s line captures that cultural contradiction: the law sells itself as settled, but it survives by improvising. Coming from an actor, it doubles as a wink: even justice needs writers’ rooms.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Bill
Add to List




