"My Lords temporal, today is the day to rise up against the regiment of Lords spiritual and proclaim the values of enlightenment, compassion and common sense"
About this Quote
Toynbee’s line is a neatly sharpened blade aimed at one of Britain’s most anachronistic arrangements: bishops in the legislature. By opening with “My Lords temporal,” she borrows the ceremonial throat-clearing of the House of Lords and flips it into a call to arms. The archaic address is the joke and the strategy: speak in the system’s own antique idiom, then use it to indict the system’s antique privileges.
The target is explicit - “Lords spiritual” - but the deeper move is to stage this as a moral contest over who gets to define the nation’s ethical baseline. “Regiment” is doing heavy lifting: it recasts clerical presence as disciplined force, not gentle guidance, implying coordinated authority rather than personal conscience. That framing matters because it makes the bishops’ votes feel less like individual contributions and more like an institutional bloc with special access.
Then comes the counter-banner: “enlightenment, compassion and common sense.” It’s an intentionally broad, crowd-pleasing triad, designed to make opposition sound irrational or mean. “Enlightenment” signals secular modernity and suspicion of revealed authority; “compassion” preempts the predictable retort that religion owns the language of care; “common sense” is the political clincher, casting reform as the obvious center rather than a radical edge.
Contextually, Toynbee is writing from inside Britain’s long culture-war stalemate: a formally established church nested inside a supposedly pluralist democracy. The intent isn’t just to win an argument about constitutional plumbing. It’s to shame the Lords temporal into remembering they’re meant to represent public reason, not defer to inherited sanctity.
The target is explicit - “Lords spiritual” - but the deeper move is to stage this as a moral contest over who gets to define the nation’s ethical baseline. “Regiment” is doing heavy lifting: it recasts clerical presence as disciplined force, not gentle guidance, implying coordinated authority rather than personal conscience. That framing matters because it makes the bishops’ votes feel less like individual contributions and more like an institutional bloc with special access.
Then comes the counter-banner: “enlightenment, compassion and common sense.” It’s an intentionally broad, crowd-pleasing triad, designed to make opposition sound irrational or mean. “Enlightenment” signals secular modernity and suspicion of revealed authority; “compassion” preempts the predictable retort that religion owns the language of care; “common sense” is the political clincher, casting reform as the obvious center rather than a radical edge.
Contextually, Toynbee is writing from inside Britain’s long culture-war stalemate: a formally established church nested inside a supposedly pluralist democracy. The intent isn’t just to win an argument about constitutional plumbing. It’s to shame the Lords temporal into remembering they’re meant to represent public reason, not defer to inherited sanctity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Polly
Add to List






