"My mind seems to have become a kind of machine for grinding general laws out of large collections of facts"
About this Quote
Darwin’s line is a quiet flex disguised as self-critique: the most world-changing kind. By comparing his mind to a machine, he strips away the romantic image of the solitary genius struck by lightning and replaces it with something almost industrial: patient intake, relentless processing, reproducible output. It’s an ethos of work more than a confession of personality, and it doubles as a defense of his method. Natural selection wasn’t born from a single dazzling insight; it was manufactured out of barnacles, finches, breeders’ notes, geological strata, and years of correspondence. The metaphor insists that theory is earned, not declared.
The subtext is also self-protective. Darwin knew what was at stake in proposing “general laws” for life: the authority of natural theology, the social volatility of his claims, the inevitable accusation that he was speculating beyond his station. So he frames himself not as a provocateur but as an instrument of facts. The machine image performs humility while asserting rigor: if the conclusions are unsettling, blame the input.
There’s a personal undertow, too. In his autobiography Darwin lamented losing a taste for poetry and music; “machine” hints at a mind specialized to the point of flattening other sensibilities. Modern readers hear an early portrait of the data-driven thinker: skeptical of grand narratives, yet hungry to distill patterns from noise. In an era that still debates whether science discovers truth or manufactures models, Darwin offers a pragmatic answer: both, and the grinding is the point.
The subtext is also self-protective. Darwin knew what was at stake in proposing “general laws” for life: the authority of natural theology, the social volatility of his claims, the inevitable accusation that he was speculating beyond his station. So he frames himself not as a provocateur but as an instrument of facts. The machine image performs humility while asserting rigor: if the conclusions are unsettling, blame the input.
There’s a personal undertow, too. In his autobiography Darwin lamented losing a taste for poetry and music; “machine” hints at a mind specialized to the point of flattening other sensibilities. Modern readers hear an early portrait of the data-driven thinker: skeptical of grand narratives, yet hungry to distill patterns from noise. In an era that still debates whether science discovers truth or manufactures models, Darwin offers a pragmatic answer: both, and the grinding is the point.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Autobiography of Charles Darwin, published within The Life and Letters of Charles Darwin, ed. Francis Darwin (1887). Contains the line: "My mind seems to have become a kind of machine for grinding general laws out of large collections of facts." |
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
