"Nature is commonplace. Imitation is more interesting"
About this Quote
Stein’s line needles the most pious assumption in Western art: that nature is the gold standard and everything else is a pale copy. She flips the hierarchy with a shrug. “Nature is commonplace” isn’t anti-nature so much as anti-reverence. The natural world is endlessly available, endlessly reproduced by mere looking. What’s scarce is the mind’s pressure on it - the stylization, the rearrangement, the deliberate wrongness that turns perception into art.
The provocation sits squarely in Stein’s modernist moment, when painting, literature, and music were breaking the contract of realism. In the Paris salons she helped define, “imitation” didn’t mean dutiful copying; it meant a chosen method, a crafted distance from the given. Cubism fractures objects to show the act of seeing; Stein’s own prose repeats, loops, and re-syntaxes until language stops being a window and becomes an object. Imitation, in that sense, is interesting because it admits its own artifice. It tells you: you’re not getting the world, you’re getting an interpretation with fingerprints on it.
There’s also a sly cultural jab here at authenticity worship. Nature stands in for whatever we treat as pure and self-evident - the “real,” the “original,” the unmediated. Stein counters that the so-called original is often just unexamined habit. Imitation, by contrast, is conscious. It exposes the rules by bending them, and in doing so, makes a new kind of truth: not faithful to appearances, but faithful to attention.
The provocation sits squarely in Stein’s modernist moment, when painting, literature, and music were breaking the contract of realism. In the Paris salons she helped define, “imitation” didn’t mean dutiful copying; it meant a chosen method, a crafted distance from the given. Cubism fractures objects to show the act of seeing; Stein’s own prose repeats, loops, and re-syntaxes until language stops being a window and becomes an object. Imitation, in that sense, is interesting because it admits its own artifice. It tells you: you’re not getting the world, you’re getting an interpretation with fingerprints on it.
There’s also a sly cultural jab here at authenticity worship. Nature stands in for whatever we treat as pure and self-evident - the “real,” the “original,” the unmediated. Stein counters that the so-called original is often just unexamined habit. Imitation, by contrast, is conscious. It exposes the rules by bending them, and in doing so, makes a new kind of truth: not faithful to appearances, but faithful to attention.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Gertrude
Add to List
