"Nature provides exceptions to every rule"
About this Quote
Rules are comforting because they promise clean edges; Fuller’s line is a quiet warning that the world refuses to stay inside them. “Nature provides exceptions to every rule” sounds like a tidy proverb until you hear the provocation underneath: if the natural world itself won’t cooperate with your categories, why should society’s categories be treated as sacred?
As a 19th-century critic and a leading voice in American transcendentalism and early feminism, Fuller was writing amid a cultural obsession with classification: new sciences sorting plants, animals, and human “types,” and a political order sorting people into rigid roles, especially by gender. Her phrasing borrows the authority of that era’s reverence for “Nature,” then flips it. Nature isn’t the enforcer of law; it’s the saboteur of certainty. The verb “provides” is key: exceptions aren’t embarrassing anomalies to be ignored; they are evidence the system is incomplete, perhaps even ideological.
The subtext reads as an argument strategy: don’t debate the rule on its own terms. Find the exception, and you destabilize the rule’s claim to universality. In a period when women’s intellectual and civic capacities were routinely declared “against nature,” Fuller’s sentence works as a scalpel. If nature itself constantly breaks patterns, then appeals to “natural” hierarchy start to look less like truth and more like convenience dressed up as inevitability.
As a 19th-century critic and a leading voice in American transcendentalism and early feminism, Fuller was writing amid a cultural obsession with classification: new sciences sorting plants, animals, and human “types,” and a political order sorting people into rigid roles, especially by gender. Her phrasing borrows the authority of that era’s reverence for “Nature,” then flips it. Nature isn’t the enforcer of law; it’s the saboteur of certainty. The verb “provides” is key: exceptions aren’t embarrassing anomalies to be ignored; they are evidence the system is incomplete, perhaps even ideological.
The subtext reads as an argument strategy: don’t debate the rule on its own terms. Find the exception, and you destabilize the rule’s claim to universality. In a period when women’s intellectual and civic capacities were routinely declared “against nature,” Fuller’s sentence works as a scalpel. If nature itself constantly breaks patterns, then appeals to “natural” hierarchy start to look less like truth and more like convenience dressed up as inevitability.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|
More Quotes by Margaret
Add to List
