"Never think that war, no matter how necessary, nor how justified, is not a crime"
About this Quote
Hemingway strips war of its alibis. The line is built to deny the reader every comfortable escape hatch: “necessary,” “justified,” even the soothing thought that moral bookkeeping can cleanse violence after the fact. By the time you reach “not a crime,” you’ve already been marched through the rationalizations that states, generals, and civilians use to launder bloodshed into duty. His syntax is a legal brief turned inside out: war may be unavoidable, but it remains indictable.
The intent isn’t pacifist softness; it’s hard-eyed accounting. Hemingway knew the seductions of wartime romance better than most writers because he’d seen how easily bravery becomes costume. Calling war a “crime” doesn’t deny courage or sacrifice; it insists those virtues don’t cancel the central act: organized killing, scaled up, bureaucratized, and narrated as necessity. The subtext is aimed at the living, not the dead: if you label war “just,” you risk treating its damage as acceptable, even cleansing. Hemingway refuses that moral anesthesia.
Context matters. A veteran of World War I’s machinery and a chronicler of conflict’s psychic residue, he writes from an era when modern warfare industrialized trauma and propaganda. The line anticipates the 20th century’s grim pattern: each side claims righteousness, then asks to be excused from reckoning. Hemingway’s point lands like a verdict: justification explains why war happens; it doesn’t absolve what it is.
The intent isn’t pacifist softness; it’s hard-eyed accounting. Hemingway knew the seductions of wartime romance better than most writers because he’d seen how easily bravery becomes costume. Calling war a “crime” doesn’t deny courage or sacrifice; it insists those virtues don’t cancel the central act: organized killing, scaled up, bureaucratized, and narrated as necessity. The subtext is aimed at the living, not the dead: if you label war “just,” you risk treating its damage as acceptable, even cleansing. Hemingway refuses that moral anesthesia.
Context matters. A veteran of World War I’s machinery and a chronicler of conflict’s psychic residue, he writes from an era when modern warfare industrialized trauma and propaganda. The line anticipates the 20th century’s grim pattern: each side claims righteousness, then asks to be excused from reckoning. Hemingway’s point lands like a verdict: justification explains why war happens; it doesn’t absolve what it is.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Ernest
Add to List
