"Nevertheless the meaning is not that the blessed bread which is divided, which is offered, and which the apostles received from the hand of Christ was not the body of Christ but becomes the body of Christ when the eating of it is begun"
About this Quote
The phrase "Nevertheless" gives away the polemical setting. He's correcting an argument he thinks is too blunt - likely a view that treats consecration as a magic moment when bread permanently changes, regardless of reception. Chemnitz insists the bread Christ breaks and offers is not "not the body" (double negative as a rhetorical guardrail), yet he refuses to let that reality float free from the act for which the sacrament exists: eating. "Becomes ... when the eating ... is begun" is a carefully calibrated hinge. It preserves real presence while tethering it to liturgical action, not priestly power or leftover objects.
The subtext is institutional as much as devotional. By anchoring the sacrament in use, Chemnitz undercuts practices like storing or parading the host as a quasi-independent holy thing, while still protecting the communicant from anxious scruples: the gift is real where Christ places it - in the giving and receiving. The repeated concrete verbs ("divided", "offered", "received") keep the argument from drifting into metaphysics. It's a theology that wants the drama of the altar to end at the table, not in the reliquary.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Chemnitz, Martin. (2026, January 18). Nevertheless the meaning is not that the blessed bread which is divided, which is offered, and which the apostles received from the hand of Christ was not the body of Christ but becomes the body of Christ when the eating of it is begun. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/nevertheless-the-meaning-is-not-that-the-blessed-22726/
Chicago Style
Chemnitz, Martin. "Nevertheless the meaning is not that the blessed bread which is divided, which is offered, and which the apostles received from the hand of Christ was not the body of Christ but becomes the body of Christ when the eating of it is begun." FixQuotes. January 18, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/nevertheless-the-meaning-is-not-that-the-blessed-22726/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Nevertheless the meaning is not that the blessed bread which is divided, which is offered, and which the apostles received from the hand of Christ was not the body of Christ but becomes the body of Christ when the eating of it is begun." FixQuotes, 18 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/nevertheless-the-meaning-is-not-that-the-blessed-22726/. Accessed 20 Feb. 2026.





