"Next in importance to freedom and justice is popular education, without which neither freedom nor justice can be permanently maintained"
About this Quote
Garfield ranks education right behind the two marquee American ideals, then twists the knife: without a broadly educated public, freedom and justice are not achievements but rentals. The line isn’t praising schooling as self-improvement; it’s arguing that democracy is a technical system with maintenance requirements. Rights on paper decay fast when the people meant to defend them can’t read the paper, track the money, or spot the con.
The wording does quiet rhetorical work. “Next in importance” flatters the civic religion of liberty while reordering its priorities: you don’t get to claim freedom as an identity if you won’t fund the conditions that keep it real. “Popular education” matters, too. Garfield isn’t talking about elite cultivation or gentlemanly polish. He means mass schooling, the kind that turns citizens from audience into participants. And “permanently maintained” carries a faintly mechanical chill, as if liberty were a bridge that collapses when you stop paying for inspections.
Context sharpens the stakes. Garfield speaks from a 19th-century America wrestling with Reconstruction’s broken promises, rapid industrialization, and political corruption. New voters were being added, old hierarchies were fighting to reassert themselves, and patronage politics made government feel like a private club. In that environment, education becomes both shield and weapon: shield against demagogues who feed on ignorance, weapon against systems that rely on people not knowing their rights or how power actually operates.
Subtext: freedom and justice aren’t just moral claims; they’re collective competencies. If you want them to last, you have to teach them.
The wording does quiet rhetorical work. “Next in importance” flatters the civic religion of liberty while reordering its priorities: you don’t get to claim freedom as an identity if you won’t fund the conditions that keep it real. “Popular education” matters, too. Garfield isn’t talking about elite cultivation or gentlemanly polish. He means mass schooling, the kind that turns citizens from audience into participants. And “permanently maintained” carries a faintly mechanical chill, as if liberty were a bridge that collapses when you stop paying for inspections.
Context sharpens the stakes. Garfield speaks from a 19th-century America wrestling with Reconstruction’s broken promises, rapid industrialization, and political corruption. New voters were being added, old hierarchies were fighting to reassert themselves, and patronage politics made government feel like a private club. In that environment, education becomes both shield and weapon: shield against demagogues who feed on ignorance, weapon against systems that rely on people not knowing their rights or how power actually operates.
Subtext: freedom and justice aren’t just moral claims; they’re collective competencies. If you want them to last, you have to teach them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List
