"Nirvana was like that- Nirvana was like the only band to come out of that- it was like the same thing, Seattle was like this whole scene and it was like this big scene that was thrust upon America"
About this Quote
Fishman’s tangle of “like”s isn’t verbal clutter so much as a musician trying to recreate, in real time, how a cultural wave actually feels when you’re standing in it: messy, half-believed, moving too fast to narrate cleanly. He’s pointing at the gap between what Seattle was (a dense, local ecosystem of clubs, friends, rival bands, DIY labels) and what America received (a simplified headline: “grunge,” with Nirvana as the face).
The line “the only band to come out of that” is telling because it’s obviously not literally true. Soundgarden, Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains, Mudhoney - the list is long. What Fishman’s really describing is the media logic of the early ’90s: one band becomes the funnel through which an entire scene is understood, marketed, and monetized. Nirvana wasn’t the sole output; it was the breakout translation. Kurt Cobain’s gift was making underground alienation legible to mainstream radio without sanding off the discomfort.
“Thrust upon America” carries a double edge: it suggests invasion and inevitability, like the country didn’t choose it so much as get hit by it. That captures the whiplash moment when hair metal gloss collapsed and a new aesthetic of sincerity, grime, and refusal became mass entertainment. Fishman, coming from a parallel live-music universe, hears how scenes get turned into products: local complexity reduced to one emblem, then shipped nationwide as a ready-made identity.
The line “the only band to come out of that” is telling because it’s obviously not literally true. Soundgarden, Pearl Jam, Alice in Chains, Mudhoney - the list is long. What Fishman’s really describing is the media logic of the early ’90s: one band becomes the funnel through which an entire scene is understood, marketed, and monetized. Nirvana wasn’t the sole output; it was the breakout translation. Kurt Cobain’s gift was making underground alienation legible to mainstream radio without sanding off the discomfort.
“Thrust upon America” carries a double edge: it suggests invasion and inevitability, like the country didn’t choose it so much as get hit by it. That captures the whiplash moment when hair metal gloss collapsed and a new aesthetic of sincerity, grime, and refusal became mass entertainment. Fishman, coming from a parallel live-music universe, hears how scenes get turned into products: local complexity reduced to one emblem, then shipped nationwide as a ready-made identity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Jon
Add to List
