"No critic writing about a film could say more than the film itself, although they do their best to make us think the oppposite"
About this Quote
Fellini’s jab lands because it’s both a defense of cinema and a sly dunk on the cottage industry that grows up around it. “No critic…could say more than the film itself” isn’t just auteur bravado; it’s a claim about the medium’s sovereignty. Film, for Fellini, is not a puzzle to be solved by smarter people in print. It’s the event. The images, rhythm, and mood carry meanings that can’t be neatly translated into verdicts and frameworks without losing their charge.
Then comes the twist of the knife: critics “do their best to make us think the oppposite.” He’s not accusing them of stupidity; he’s accusing them of professional necessity. Criticism survives by implying that the real movie is the one that happens after the credits: the interpretation, the ranking, the cultural positioning. If a film could be fully “said,” the critic’s authority collapses. So the critic is incentivized to perform mastery, to treat cinema like raw material awaiting refinement into language.
The subtext is especially Fellini: a filmmaker associated with dreams, excess, and subjective truth bristling at the idea that meaning is a courtroom transcript. Coming from an era when European auteurs were being canonized and aggressively theorized, the line doubles as a warning. Criticism can illuminate, sure, but it can also colonize the viewer’s experience, teaching audiences to distrust their own eyes in favor of the “correct” reading. Fellini’s punchline is a reminder: the movie is the argument. Everything else is commentary trying to compete with it.
Then comes the twist of the knife: critics “do their best to make us think the oppposite.” He’s not accusing them of stupidity; he’s accusing them of professional necessity. Criticism survives by implying that the real movie is the one that happens after the credits: the interpretation, the ranking, the cultural positioning. If a film could be fully “said,” the critic’s authority collapses. So the critic is incentivized to perform mastery, to treat cinema like raw material awaiting refinement into language.
The subtext is especially Fellini: a filmmaker associated with dreams, excess, and subjective truth bristling at the idea that meaning is a courtroom transcript. Coming from an era when European auteurs were being canonized and aggressively theorized, the line doubles as a warning. Criticism can illuminate, sure, but it can also colonize the viewer’s experience, teaching audiences to distrust their own eyes in favor of the “correct” reading. Fellini’s punchline is a reminder: the movie is the argument. Everything else is commentary trying to compete with it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Federico
Add to List



