"No good poem, however confessional it may be, is just a self-expression. Who on earth would claim that the pearl expresses the oyster?"
About this Quote
Confession is the lure here, and C. Day Lewis snaps it shut with a clean, slightly disdainful metaphor. He’s pushing back on the cozy idea that a poem is simply a diary with line breaks. Even when a poem sounds nakedly personal, he argues, it’s not the self speaking unfiltered; it’s the self processed, shaped, pressured into form. The pearl image is doing heavy work: pearls come from irritation, time, and accretion, not from an oyster’s desire to “express” anything. That undercuts the modern romance of authenticity-as-truth. What matters isn’t sincerity alone, but the craft that turns raw grit into a hard, luminous object you can hold.
The subtext is a defense of art’s impersonality without denying feeling. Day Lewis isn’t sneering at confessional intensity; he’s insisting that intensity isn’t enough. A poem becomes public not because it overshares, but because it converts private material into a made thing with its own integrity. The jab “Who on earth would claim…” is a social correction: if you’re treating poems as therapeutic transcripts, you’re missing the point and insulting the labor.
Context matters: Day Lewis came up in a 1930s British literary world where poets were expected to be socially serious, technically disciplined, and suspicious of mere self-display. Writing in the long shadow of Eliot’s “impersonal theory” and before “Confessional Poetry” became a brand, he’s warning against reducing art to personality. The poem isn’t the oyster talking; it’s what the oyster, under pressure, manages to produce.
The subtext is a defense of art’s impersonality without denying feeling. Day Lewis isn’t sneering at confessional intensity; he’s insisting that intensity isn’t enough. A poem becomes public not because it overshares, but because it converts private material into a made thing with its own integrity. The jab “Who on earth would claim…” is a social correction: if you’re treating poems as therapeutic transcripts, you’re missing the point and insulting the labor.
Context matters: Day Lewis came up in a 1930s British literary world where poets were expected to be socially serious, technically disciplined, and suspicious of mere self-display. Writing in the long shadow of Eliot’s “impersonal theory” and before “Confessional Poetry” became a brand, he’s warning against reducing art to personality. The poem isn’t the oyster talking; it’s what the oyster, under pressure, manages to produce.
Quote Details
| Topic | Poetry |
|---|
More Quotes by Day Lewis
Add to List
