"No, I only like whether I like the story or not, essentially see something in it that isn't completely there"
About this Quote
Minnelli is quietly rejecting the polite fiction that taste is a checklist: theme, message, relevance, prestige. His “No” lands like a door closing on dutiful criticism. What follows is a director’s credo built on instinct and projection. He doesn’t “judge” a story so much as test whether it gives him room to hallucinate - to “see something in it that isn’t completely there.” That phrase is the tell: the material doesn’t have to arrive fully formed. It has to be porous.
The subtext is almost provocative in its humility. Minnelli, one of classical Hollywood’s great stylists, is admitting that the work begins as an incomplete object, and that incompleteness isn’t a flaw; it’s an invitation. A story that’s too sealed off, too self-satisfied, leaves no oxygen for direction. A story with gaps lets him do what his films do best: turn psychology into architecture, feeling into color, desire into choreography. His musicals and melodramas aren’t just “adaptations” of scripts - they’re expansions, where the camera and design finish sentences the dialogue can’t.
Context matters: Minnelli comes out of theater and MGM’s factory system, where directors often navigated pre-sold properties and rigid production pipelines. Against that machinery, he’s staking a personal criterion that sounds almost anti-industrial: not “Is it good?” but “Can I complete it?” It’s also a neat statement of auteur power without the swagger. He’s saying the story is a starting line, not a commandment.
The subtext is almost provocative in its humility. Minnelli, one of classical Hollywood’s great stylists, is admitting that the work begins as an incomplete object, and that incompleteness isn’t a flaw; it’s an invitation. A story that’s too sealed off, too self-satisfied, leaves no oxygen for direction. A story with gaps lets him do what his films do best: turn psychology into architecture, feeling into color, desire into choreography. His musicals and melodramas aren’t just “adaptations” of scripts - they’re expansions, where the camera and design finish sentences the dialogue can’t.
Context matters: Minnelli comes out of theater and MGM’s factory system, where directors often navigated pre-sold properties and rigid production pipelines. Against that machinery, he’s staking a personal criterion that sounds almost anti-industrial: not “Is it good?” but “Can I complete it?” It’s also a neat statement of auteur power without the swagger. He’s saying the story is a starting line, not a commandment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Vincente
Add to List




