"No lying knight or lying priest ever prospered in any age, but especially not in the dark ones. Men prospered then only in following an openly declared purpose, and preaching candidly beloved and trusted creeds"
About this Quote
Ruskin doesn’t just scold hypocrisy here; he rewrites the usual story we tell about the Middle Ages. The cliché is that “dark ones” were an era where cunning clerics and violent nobles could get away with anything. Ruskin flips that: in conditions of scarcity, ignorance, and constant risk, the social penalty for deception is higher, not lower. When institutions are fragile, trust becomes infrastructure. A “lying knight” or “lying priest” doesn’t merely commit a private sin; he sabotages the only currency that keeps a community from collapsing into vendetta and chaos.
The line works because it’s moral argument disguised as historical observation. “Ever prospered” is absolute on purpose: Ruskin wants to shame the Victorian confidence trickster and the polite bureaucratic liar by implying their “success” is temporary, cosmetic, and finally self-defeating. The specificity of “knight” and “priest” targets the two medieval monopolies on force and meaning: the sword and the sermon. If those roles lie, the whole world becomes illegible.
“Openly declared purpose” and “candidly beloved and trusted creeds” are doing double duty. On the surface, Ruskin praises sincerity; underneath, he’s warning his own industrial age about the dangers of managerial doublespeak and market-driven ethics. He’s not nostalgic for feudalism so much as for legibility: a society where power states its aims plainly and belief is binding enough to be held accountable. The dark age, in Ruskin’s telling, isn’t defined by superstition but by consequences.
The line works because it’s moral argument disguised as historical observation. “Ever prospered” is absolute on purpose: Ruskin wants to shame the Victorian confidence trickster and the polite bureaucratic liar by implying their “success” is temporary, cosmetic, and finally self-defeating. The specificity of “knight” and “priest” targets the two medieval monopolies on force and meaning: the sword and the sermon. If those roles lie, the whole world becomes illegible.
“Openly declared purpose” and “candidly beloved and trusted creeds” are doing double duty. On the surface, Ruskin praises sincerity; underneath, he’s warning his own industrial age about the dangers of managerial doublespeak and market-driven ethics. He’s not nostalgic for feudalism so much as for legibility: a society where power states its aims plainly and belief is binding enough to be held accountable. The dark age, in Ruskin’s telling, isn’t defined by superstition but by consequences.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List






