"No man is the wiser for his learning; it may administer matter to work in, or objects to work upon; but wit and wisdom are born with a man"
About this Quote
Selden’s line lands like a slap at the early-modern faith in bookish improvement: don’t mistake accumulated knowledge for actual judgment. As a statesman and legal scholar moving through England’s civil and religious upheavals, he’d seen “learning” weaponized by universities, clergy, and courtiers alike - a credentialed sheen that could sanctify bad arguments and bad policy. The point isn’t anti-intellectualism; it’s anti-pretension. Learning “administers matter,” he concedes, like supplying timber and tools. But the house still depends on the builder.
The subtext is a warning about governance. In Selden’s world, the educated elite claimed authority by citing sources - canon law, classical precedent, scripture - as if quotation were competence. Selden separates inputs from faculties: facts and texts can expand what you can work with, but they can’t guarantee you’ll work well. “Wit and wisdom” here are less party tricks than native discernment: the ability to size up motives, anticipate consequences, and spot the clever lie dressed as reason.
It works rhetorically because it punctures the meritocracy myth before that myth even fully hardens. The sentence structure performs the distinction: learning is external, administered, additive; wisdom is internal, born, constitutive. That fatalism is part of the bite. Selden isn’t offering a self-help plan; he’s policing status claims. If you’re in power, don’t hide behind your library. If you’re impressed by power, don’t confuse a well-read man with a wise one.
The subtext is a warning about governance. In Selden’s world, the educated elite claimed authority by citing sources - canon law, classical precedent, scripture - as if quotation were competence. Selden separates inputs from faculties: facts and texts can expand what you can work with, but they can’t guarantee you’ll work well. “Wit and wisdom” here are less party tricks than native discernment: the ability to size up motives, anticipate consequences, and spot the clever lie dressed as reason.
It works rhetorically because it punctures the meritocracy myth before that myth even fully hardens. The sentence structure performs the distinction: learning is external, administered, additive; wisdom is internal, born, constitutive. That fatalism is part of the bite. Selden isn’t offering a self-help plan; he’s policing status claims. If you’re in power, don’t hide behind your library. If you’re impressed by power, don’t confuse a well-read man with a wise one.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | John Selden , Wikiquote entry (en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Selden) lists the quotation: "No man is the wiser for his learning; it may administer matter to work in, or objects to work upon; but wit and wisdom are born with a man". |
More Quotes by John
Add to List













