"No more doth it hurt to say that the body and blood are not in the sacrament"
About this Quote
Tyndale writes like a man picking a fight with an entire sacramental economy and refusing to flinch. The line looks mild, almost procedural: it “hurts” no more to deny Christ’s bodily presence in the Eucharist than to state any other theological proposition. That calmness is the blade. In a culture where rejecting transubstantiation wasn’t an abstract disagreement but a prosecutable offense, the understated phrasing performs bravery as plain speech, not heroism.
The specific intent is polemical and pastoral at once. Tyndale is reassuring the wavering reader: you can say this out loud. You can name what Rome has made unspeakable. The subtext is that the Church’s power depends on enforcing a metaphysics that can’t be tested but can be policed. If the “body and blood” are not literally there, then the priest’s unique authority to “make” Christ present begins to look less like sacred mediation and more like institutional leverage.
Context sharpens the stakes. Tyndale, the English reformer and translator who helped push Scripture into the vernacular, is operating in the combustible early Reformation, when Eucharistic doctrine was a fault line separating obedience from heresy. His formulation also nods to a re-centered piety: faith anchored in the Word and inward trust, not in a material miracle managed by clergy.
The rhetorical trick is its restraint. By shrinking a capital crime into a simple sentence, Tyndale exposes the violence required to keep certain ideas “dangerous.”
The specific intent is polemical and pastoral at once. Tyndale is reassuring the wavering reader: you can say this out loud. You can name what Rome has made unspeakable. The subtext is that the Church’s power depends on enforcing a metaphysics that can’t be tested but can be policed. If the “body and blood” are not literally there, then the priest’s unique authority to “make” Christ present begins to look less like sacred mediation and more like institutional leverage.
Context sharpens the stakes. Tyndale, the English reformer and translator who helped push Scripture into the vernacular, is operating in the combustible early Reformation, when Eucharistic doctrine was a fault line separating obedience from heresy. His formulation also nods to a re-centered piety: faith anchored in the Word and inward trust, not in a material miracle managed by clergy.
The rhetorical trick is its restraint. By shrinking a capital crime into a simple sentence, Tyndale exposes the violence required to keep certain ideas “dangerous.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List



